News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Amazon and the "profitless business model" fallacy by pbreit on Sunday October 27, 2013 @02:08AM (#6620978)
Can you explain how capital expenditures do not affect profits? Doesn't capitalization just mean that expenses are applied over time? They don't disappear, correct?
Re:Amazon and the "profitless business model" fallacy by hristov on Sunday October 27, 2013 @06:03AM (#6621453)
Capital expenses do not affect profits for the reporting period they happen in. It is true that after that reporting period there is a depreciation cost applied to take account of loss of value of an asset.

For example, if a company buys a distribution center, it will not expense the cost of the distribution center as an expense. But as time goes on it will expense a depreciation expense that accounts for the loss of value of the distribution center as the building gets older, less useful, etc. But buildings last for a long time, and a building with the land it is on never actually goes down to a value of zero. So not all expenses associated with the distribution center will be applied over time.

So capitalizing something definitely helps you get more income.

Re:Amazon and the "profitless business model" fallacy by PeterisP on Sunday October 27, 2013 @08:08AM (#6621689)
Capitalizing doesn't help you "get" more income, it simply allows you to write some of the same income in an earlier year.
Re:Amazon and the "profitless business model" fallacy by pbreit on Sunday October 27, 2013 @01:19PM (#6622590)
So all capital expenditures reduce income. That's what I thought. I've never understood why folks don't think "pay later" = "pay".
Re:Amazon and the "profitless business model" fallacy by mseebach on Sunday October 27, 2013 @01:20PM (#6622595)
Profit is how much your total assets have increased in value. Cash is an asset and a warehouse is an asset. If you spend $1m of your cash that would otherwise have been cash profits to build a warehouse worth $1m, your total assets remain the same and thus your profits remain the same.

But, unlike cash, a building doesn't retain its (dollar) value forever, it must be written off. I'm not sure how buildings are written off since they have a rather long "shelf" life, but laptops are generally written off over three year. So if you buy a $1500 laptop with cash in year 0, your profits in year zero are unaffected, but you must book a depreciation (a reduction in the value of your assets) worth $500 in years 1, 2 and 3. Hopefully you will, as with your warehouse, use your new asset to book profits in each of these years in excess of your write-offs.

Re:Amazon and the "profitless business model" fallacy by MaysonL on Sunday October 27, 2013 @02:40AM (#6621048)
Last quarter, Amazon had 834M of depreciation, and 281M of stock-based compensation: 1.1 billion of non-cash deductions from revenue. They made capital expenditures of 1.03 billion. They ended the quarter with about $100 million more cash than they started with.
Re:Amazon and the "profitless business model" fallacy by cperciva on Sunday October 27, 2013 @04:55AM (#6621319)
281M of stock-based compensation ... ended the quarter with about $100 million more cash than they started with.

This looks like a loss to me. They could have sold $281M of stock and gotten $281M in cash; instead they ended up $181M short of that.

Re:Amazon and the "profitless business model" fallacy by michaelt on Sunday October 27, 2013 @05:42AM (#6621404)
In general when you're a CEO or board member you'll make more money by granting yourself $x million in stock than you'll make by paying a dividend of $x million which has to be shared among all investors.
Re:Amazon and the "profitless business model" fallacy by encoderer on Sunday October 27, 2013 @01:19PM (#6622591)
Not to mention, there are tax benefits to stock based comp. First, you often have the choice of when to exercise the stock which can make a world of difference especially with AMT, and second, if you hold for a year you'll pay the long term cap gains rate. For lower income people (hehe in this case that would be people who make less than $400k) that's still 15% which is an incredible discount. For higher income folks it's now about 23% but, again, that represents a tidy discount against their marginal tax rate.
Re:Amazon and the "profitless business model" fallacy by dlgeek on Sunday October 27, 2013 @07:09AM (#6621572)
Bezos doesn't take any stock-based compensation and takes only a minimal salary (less than 90K/year).

He makes money by increasing the value of his existing stock.

Re:Amazon and the "profitless business model" fallacy by moca on Sunday October 27, 2013 @02:34AM (#6621039)
Yes. Capital expenditures don't disappear. You can buy a piece of land to build a warehouse. You can sell the land to get money back if needed, so you can't report the money for the land as loss.
Re:Amazon and the "profitless business model" fallacy by 001sky on Sunday October 27, 2013 @02:14AM (#6620998)
Amazon has ~no profits before taking into account the ways that Capex (might) impact profits.