News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why I Stopped Selling My Time for a Living by dragonwriter on Saturday October 26, 2013 @08:38PM (#6620157)
> In a regular 9-5 job you’re selling your time to an employer

> Or, to look at it another way, you are collaborating with a number of colleagues to develop and sell software, and you are all sharing the income. See how that's the same thing, phrased differently?

But it is clearly not the same thing phrased differently. The first is an accurate description of a wage labor relationship, the latter is an accurate description of the relation between members of a labor cooperative. You can imagine that the latter relationship is the case when you are in the former relationship, but self-delusion probably isn't useful or healthy in the long term.

Re:Why I Stopped Selling My Time for a Living by matthewmacleod on Saturday October 26, 2013 @08:58PM (#6620239)
> But it is clearly not the same thing phrased differently. The first is an accurate description of a wage labor relationship, the latter is an accurate description of the relation between members of a labor cooperative. You can imagine that the latter relationship is the case when you are in the former relationship, but self-delusion probably isn't useful or healthy in the long term.

I disagree that this is self-delusion, and that's a thoroughly unhelpful attitude - you are just choosing to emphasise a different set of facts, which does not invalidate the other.

There are absolutely loads of jobs out there for a talented developer at this point in time. You can essentially select any team you want, and name your price - the upshot is that this moves so much power away from employers that the relationship is pretty far away from wage slavery.

Re:Why I Stopped Selling My Time for a Living by cgag on Saturday October 26, 2013 @08:46PM (#6620184)
Yes, I find this kind of self deception about the nature of a job much more disturbing than having a negative attitude about having someone else tell you what to do and when to do it. You're collaborating with colleagues to build software for someone else to sell, over which you retain no rights, and you receive a flat rate in the face of growing profits.
Re:Why I Stopped Selling My Time for a Living by matthewmacleod on Saturday October 26, 2013 @09:08PM (#6620269)
That's the result if you work for a bad team, sure. In my case, I develop software that my colleagues sell and support (and they're nice guys.) I have input into what we build and how we do it. Yeah, I don't retain the rights, but I do get to publish a bit of open-source. And I know first-hand that I'm not alone in having a good working environment with an employer.

Your argument seem to be that it's better to be in charge - and sure, I think we'd all ultimately like that. But that comes with costs—in some cases, pretty large ones—and it's a mistake to gloss over them so lightly.

Re:Why I Stopped Selling My Time for a Living by dragonwriter on Sunday October 27, 2013 @11:31AM (#6622216)
> That's the result if you work for a bad team, sure.

It's the result if you work for wage labor, period. You're not "sharing the profits", you're paid a negotiated rent for your time which is not dependent on the profits. Even if you get some kind of equity or profit-sharing component of your compensation, the basic relationship is still of time rent.

> And I know first-hand that I'm not alone in having a good working environment with an employer.

Having a good working environment with an employer doesn't change the basic relationship from "selling time to an employer" to "sharing the income", in the same way that having a good working environment with a slave master -- which undoubtedly there were slaves who did -- doesn't change the relationship from "being someone else's chattel" to "selling time to an employer".

And if you have to tell yourself a comforting lie about what the basic nature of the relationship is to be happy about it, I think that may be a signal that the "good working environment" isn't so good.

If you are really happy with what the relationship is, that you wouldn't need to misrepresent it.

Re:Why I Stopped Selling My Time for a Living by matthewmacleod on Sunday October 27, 2013 @11:57AM (#6622311)
>And if you have to tell yourself a comforting lie about what the basic nature of the relationship is to be happy about it, I think that may be a signal that the "good working environment" isn't so good.

Okay - I'll bow out here. I think you've probably latched on to a minor detail that's not really relevant — my main point being that focusing on "selling time to an employer" is only one interpretation of the employee-employer relationship. Maybe I could have described it as "charging a fixed rate to a client and doing interesting research" – the point is, in a market such as the current one for software developers, employment is as much under the control of the employee as the employer.

To be clear, I don't have any intention of misrepresenting or lying about my work environment, so please don't make such assumptions.

Re:Why I Stopped Selling My Time for a Living by jamesaguilar on Saturday October 26, 2013 @08:52PM (#6620214)
Actually the selling time version is not really accurate either. What you're selling is the product of your time and skill. And if you substitute "income" for "part of the income," well, the grandparent's phrasing is an accurate description of what is happening (in that no part of the description is untrue). You my prefer to emphasize a different set of facts, but that doesn't mean you get to say a true thing is not true.
Re:Why I Stopped Selling My Time for a Living by dragonwriter on Sunday October 27, 2013 @11:32AM (#6622219)
> Actually the selling time version is not really accurate either.

No, that's exactly what wage labor is by definition.