News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Billionaires’ Row and Welfare Lines by jgalt212 on Saturday October 26, 2013 @04:31PM (#6619191)
Many of these billionaires are undeserved and unearned billionaires because of the carried interest tax dodge. That needs to go ASAP. Over five years into a Democrat presidency and all these tax issues (low taxes on dividends, double irish corp tax dodge, etc) that protect the uber wealthy persist.

It's not about taxing the wealthy, it's about fairness. $85K earned by a teacher, $150K earned by a developer, $20M earned by Brad Pitt and $200M earned by Steve Schwarzman should all be taxed the same way.

And the same goes for corp earnings. F Apple! Pay your taxes.

Top 10 Private Equity Tax Loopholes http://dealbook.nytimes.com/2013/04/15/the-top-10-private-eq...

Re:Billionaires’ Row and Welfare Lines by yummyfajitas on Saturday October 26, 2013 @04:50PM (#6619291)
If you want to tax everyone the same, eliminate taxes on corporations and have an income tax when money moves from a corporation to a human. This would drastically simplify many things - loss carryforwards, depreciation schedules, etc.

But comparing the 35% corporate income tax + 15% long term capital gains (less inflation) [1] that Steve Schwarzman pays to the roughly 30% that the teacher pays is silly. The teacher pays far less, but these facile comparisons ignore most of what's really happening.

[1] Or 35% corporate income tax + 39.6% dividend, since you specifically singled out dividends. Or maybe 35% corporate income + 20% qualified dividend, depending on how it all works out.

Re:Billionaires’ Row and Welfare Lines by m3mnoch on Saturday October 26, 2013 @05:11PM (#6619385)
or when everyone sets up corporations, take a dollar salary, and run all of their expenses through petty cash?
Re:Billionaires’ Row and Welfare Lines by yummyfajitas on Saturday October 26, 2013 @05:12PM (#6619388)
I'm sure no one ever thought of this before, and the IRS certainly does not have extensive experience in putting a quick stop to this.
Re:Billionaires’ Row and Welfare Lines by devx on Saturday October 26, 2013 @04:55PM (#6619312)
What happens when more and more types of jobs are becoming automated?
Re:Billionaires’ Row and Welfare Lines by w4 on Saturday October 26, 2013 @05:08PM (#6619372)
Then the individuals reaping the rewards of automation (the owners) see greater taxes as a function of those increased returns.
Re:Billionaires’ Row and Welfare Lines by a3voices on Saturday October 26, 2013 @05:16PM (#6619411)
A basic income should be implemented eventually, in my opinion.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Basic_income

Re:Billionaires’ Row and Welfare Lines by danielamitay on Saturday October 26, 2013 @04:39PM (#6619224)
Without addressing the issue of tax loopholes in general, there is a logical rationale for lower taxes on capital gains (for Schwarzman, Buffett & co):

- It's a double tax, as money that was invested had already been previously taxed.

- It does not account for inflation. If an investment grows only with inflation, capital gains taxes still need to be paid on that growth.

Re:Billionaires’ Row and Welfare Lines by gamblor956 on Saturday October 26, 2013 @04:49PM (#6619289)
A capital gains tax is not double-taxation, as the tax applies only to "gains" on a capital investment, and these gains have not yet been subject to tax. Moreover, most capital investments are made using untaxed amounts (i.e., "reinvested" income), as part of transactions designed to avoid paying taxes.

A capital gains tax is not intended to account for inflation--the persons that pay the capital gains tax (companies and wealthy individuals) are least subject to inflation. The lower rate was intended as an incentive to make capital investments in businesses. Unfortunately, due to the way capital assets are defined (or rather, is not defined) in the tax code, the lower rate has instead resulted in excessive investment in real properties, illusory assets (i.e., derivatives), and other passive investments rather than in businesses.

Re:Billionaires’ Row and Welfare Lines by yummyfajitas on Saturday October 26, 2013 @04:53PM (#6619303)
Say you have a business worth $100k. It earns another $100k and pays 35% corporate tax on it. The rest goes into the bank. The company is now worth $165k. If you sell the company for $165k, you pay cap gains taxes on the $65k gain - at 20% qualified cap gains rate, you walk away with a gain of $52k.

That's what double taxation means. You paid taxes twice on the earnings of $100k.

[edit: it might shock some of you to discover that this is a simplified example to illustrate the point.]

Re:Billionaires’ Row and Welfare Lines by gamblor956 on Saturday October 26, 2013 @10:57PM (#6620578)
I don't think you understand what double taxation means. Double taxation refers to a specific item of income.

You own a company, X. It earns income of 100 doing whatever. That income is taxed. This is the first level of taxation. The company then distributes that income as a dividend to its shareholder, you. That dividend is income to you. Thus, it is subject to tax again. This is the second level of taxation. If you had performed the income-generating activity directly (i.e., not through the company), it would not be subject to this second level of tax. However, at the same time, the use of the corporate entity provides significant legal and tax benefits. Thus, the double taxation is mitigated but not eliminated.

Another example: Company X, based in the U.S., does some business in France. France taxes that income. That is the first level of taxation. The U.S. also taxes that income, due to its worldwide taxation system. That is the second level of tax on the same income. In this particular instance, we have a treaty with tax to eliminate the double taxation of that same income. (This is not true of all countries, for example, we don't have a tax treaty with Taiwan.)

In your example, you ignore the basic system of US and EU capital gains taxation. When you sell a business, you are generally taxed based on the difference between [sale price] subtract [your "cost basis"] in the business. (Cost basis generally means the amount you paid to acquire the shares, or which you contributed to the business.) It is irrelevant that your business was worth $100k before it made another $100k--the tax code doesn't look at intermediary valuations, and it doesn't care about earnings when determining the tax on the sale of a capital asset. What matters is whether you have a "cost basis" in your shares of the business. If you acquired your shares for $0 (for example, you contributed your labor to earn those shares), then upon selling the business in your example you would recognize capital gains of $165k, not $65k. Usually, capital gain from the sale of a business relates to "goodwill" (i.e., brand value) rather than cash from earnings (and for property or other capital assets, capital gains are usually due to simple appreciation.) Double taxation is not usually a problem with capital assets, so the capital gains rate does not reflect a discount to remedy double taxation. Rather, capital gains rates are discounted to encourage investment in capital assets.

Re:Billionaires’ Row and Welfare Lines by yummyfajitas on Sunday October 27, 2013 @03:01AM (#6621095)
If you acquired your shares for $0 (for example, you contributed your labor to earn those shares), then upon selling the business in your example you would recognize capital gains of $165k, not $65k.

Yes, I was assuming you purchased at $100k to illustrate the cost basis. I should have been more clear on that point.

If you want to argue that double taxation is justified as the price of limited liability, go ahead. But it's silly to compare the capital gains rate to the income tax and then ignore the corporate tax rate. Combined they amount to a lot more than personal income taxes. This is why the wealthy contribute such a disproportionate amount to the US treasury.

Re:Billionaires’ Row and Welfare Lines by _delirium on Tuesday October 29, 2013 @11:23PM (#6639261)
> the wealthy contribute such a disproportionate amount to the US treasury.

Overall US taxes (from all sources) are approximately flat taxes, if considered relative to wealth, as you seem to be doing. The wealthy contribute roughly the same share of their wealth to the treasury as the less wealthy do. The 90th-percentile-and-above of richest Americans own about 75% of the country's assets in aggregate, and pay about 75% of the country's taxes in aggregate.

Re:Billionaires’ Row and Welfare Lines by beagle3 on Saturday October 26, 2013 @05:24PM (#6619458)
> That's what double taxation means. You paid taxes twice on the earnings of $100k.

You paid 48% on the $100K, and that is all that matters in the end - the fact that it was a two step process, and that different steps have different credit/exemptions consideration is not really important.

And you generally can pay just your marginal rate - don't set up a corporation, and list everything on your own return - singular taxation goodness!.

However, no one likes to do that, because it makes them personally liable. So actually the higher rate (which people like to call "double taxation" even though that's not informative) turns out to be the fee you have to pay to separate your finances and legal status from the business - and by the fact that the vast majority of businesses choose it indicates that, in general, it's not expensive and might even be too cheap for what it provides.

Re:Billionaires’ Row and Welfare Lines by tzs on Saturday October 26, 2013 @05:15PM (#6619406)
Wouldn't the $65k raise your basis in the now $165k company by $65k?, and so it would have affect on your recognized gains?
Re:Billionaires’ Row and Welfare Lines by gamblor956 on Saturday October 26, 2013 @11:00PM (#6620580)
No. Cash earned by a corporation does not affect the basis of its shareholders. If such cash earnings were distributed as a dividend, it would not affect the basis of its shareholders but would be taxable as income to the shareholders.

(Cash distributed by a corporation but which is not earned, i.e.,if the corporation has negative earnings at the time of the distribution, would reduce the shareholder's basis.)

If you were dealing with a partnership/LLC, the $65k would generally increase its partners' basis in the partnership/LLC. However, in such case you wouldn't be dealing with double taxation in the first place.

Re:Billionaires’ Row and Welfare Lines by jgalt212 on Saturday October 26, 2013 @05:51PM (#6619561)
The carried interest tax loophole is not about taxing investment gains at a lower rate, it's about letting PE/HF/VC types turned earnings realized from money management services into fake long term capital gains.

Furthermore, HF managers pay less taxes on their earnings than their investors do b/c HF investment gains are short term capital gains but the fees collected for managing such short term gains get taxed at the lower long term rate.

There is no fairness, or logic in that scenario.

Re:Billionaires’ Row and Welfare Lines by beagle3 on Saturday October 26, 2013 @05:19PM (#6619429)
> It's a double tax, as money that was invested had already been previously taxed.

Everything has, in some form of another, been previously taxed. "Double taxation" is a good sound bite, but it doesn't actually say anything. yummyfajitas gives a computation below that shows the overall tax rate is higher (48%). That is an actual argument (which I will respond to there). But other than that, "double taxation" means nothing other than "different rates", which is generally always the case.

Re:Billionaires’ Row and Welfare Lines by MaysonL on Saturday October 26, 2013 @04:50PM (#6619293)
It also ignores the effect of compound interest: capital gains earned over 10 years are only taxed once, not 10 times, as they perhaps should be.
Re:Billionaires’ Row and Welfare Lines by kenster07 on Saturday October 26, 2013 @05:22PM (#6619445)
That is only one definition of fairness. Another definition of fairness would declare: "No Mr. Multi-millionaire, you really don't need a 5th Ferrari, just because you won the genetic lottery." I see the merit to both sides, because I can see myself on both sides. But nonetheless, your proposal would be an improvement, because right now, the system we have is neither fair nor sustainable.
Re:Billionaires’ Row and Welfare Lines by Shivetya on Saturday October 26, 2013 @04:56PM (#6619316)
Don't worry the ACA is there to help those who make less, oh wait its not, its the biggest transfer of wealth from the young and able to the rich and old in generations.

Corporate tax rates are too high in the US, however those are balanced out by far too many write offs. Drop the rate, remove the deductions, and that should help.

Re:Billionaires’ Row and Welfare Lines by chrislipa on Saturday October 26, 2013 @04:42PM (#6619244)
> low taxes on dividends

My understanding is that the low nominal tax on dividends is on top of the high corporate tax, which is 35%, so that dividends are taxed at a higher rate than earned income.

Re:Billionaires’ Row and Welfare Lines by beagle3 on Saturday October 26, 2013 @05:32PM (#6619488)
These things are extremely hard to compare.

Yes, it is on top of the 35%. However, the 35% is on pure profit -- if the business has more expenses, the profit goes down and there is less tax. Whereas, if it was earned income, there are much fewer relevant deductions.

Also, being a corporate does indeed cost that 35% corporate tax - however, it does limit the shareholder, director and officer liability. If the corporate structure wasn't there, these people would have to arrange for e.g. insurance - and the overall cost would be at least as high.

I would infer from the fact that most small business owners choose the "limited liability" path, that the overall cost (corporate tax + dividend tax) is worth the limited liability. It might, in fact, be too cheap for what it provides.

Re:Billionaires’ Row and Welfare Lines by gamblor956 on Saturday October 26, 2013 @11:04PM (#6620595)
The LLC form provides the best of both: limited legal liability, while eliminating the double taxation burden. This is one of the reasons the form has been taking off over the past 2 decades, especially for small businesses.