Re:reCAPTCHAs are finally readable by normal humans
by toggle on Friday October 25, 2013 @11:49PM
(#6616240)
No no, the hidden input fields would not be filled in by a human (because they're positioned off screen by CSS, for example), whereas a bot would fill them in because the bot is just scraping the HTML for all input fields and filling them in with something.
It seems like you had that backwards -- hope that clears it up.
Re:reCAPTCHAs are finally readable by normal humans
by tokenizerrr on Saturday October 26, 2013 @12:41AM
(#6616375)
Why would I have my bot fill them in? One glance at the site and I know that my bot should skip those fields.
Re:reCAPTCHAs are finally readable by normal humans
by matchu on Saturday October 26, 2013 @12:53AM
(#6616397)
It's meant as a defense against non-targeted bots—the ones that roam the web looking for forms to fill out.
I think that's where the issue lies: these tools do different things. Honeypot fields defend against general bots. Captchas defend against specific bots, too, but also have greater friction, so are only used when specific bots are an issue.
Re:reCAPTCHAs are finally readable by normal humans
by Larrikin on Saturday October 26, 2013 @02:49AM
(#6616629)
I did my mom's website for her small law firm and I was getting tons of bots even with hidden form fields and they didn't look targetted. Captcha helped a lot but the spam didn't stop until I used both combined with special rules, like the phone number field has to have a certain amount of numbers.
Re:reCAPTCHAs are finally readable by normal humans
by FiloSottile on Monday October 28, 2013 @04:51PM
(#6629695)
Ok, I thought it was intended as a counter-measure to targeted bots.
Umh, anything that will end up in the POST request will be reproduced by a bot, I don't even actually look at the page when implementing screen scraping modules, but just at the Network tab of the Chrome Dev Tools.
What I think have the potential to remove the need for conscious CAPTCHA solving is what Google is supposedly doing here: machine learning on behavioral patterns in the user interaction with the form (instead of just with the CAPTCHA).