News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Snapchat Is Mulling Another Huge Round at a $3.5 Billion ... by programminggeek on Friday October 25, 2013 @03:28PM (#6613941)
Does anyone else find this valuation incredibly ironic given that in 1999 Yahoo! bought Geocities for $3.57 billion?

I mean, does anyone believe that Snapchat is going to ever be a service that brings in billions of dollars in revenue?

Re:Snapchat Is Mulling Another Huge Round at a $3.5 Billion ... by potatolicious on Friday October 25, 2013 @03:34PM (#6613978)
This is IMO the wrong way to look at it. Look at this more like Instagram.

Neither Snapchat nor Instagram are creating new traffic. What they are doing is essentially stealing marketshare and user engagement from competing services like Facebook and Twitter.

Their valuation isn't their revenue potential, it's the opportunity cost to Facebook, Twitter, et al for letting them survive.

If Snapchat is stealing $1bn of monetizable traffic from Facebook, Facebook would be wised to pay some amount of money (<$1bn) to either shut it down or bring them into the fold.

There is some extra valuation here in fucking your competitor over. Acquisition of hot social media companies like this is equal parts adding monetizable traffic to your network (traffic they may have taken from you in the first place...), as well as denying your competitors the ability to do the same.

So, say if Twitter acquires Snapchat, their valuation will be some combination of ${traffic_twitter_loses_to_snapchat} + ${traffic_facebook_loses_to_snapchat} + ${value_in_denying_facebook_access_to_this_traffic}

Whether or not that's worth $3.5bn is questionable, but there is some reason behind valuing non-revenue-generating products with a positive valuation.

The main "bubble" part here is whether or not this is at all sustainable (IMO, probably not). It's pretty easy to create something that steals an appreciable amount of traffic from the incumbent social network behemoths. At these valuations the cost to "recover" these eyeballs far exceeds how much the traffic is actually worth in ad revenue.

Re:Snapchat Is Mulling Another Huge Round at a $3.5 Billion ... by rexreed on Friday October 25, 2013 @03:44PM (#6614042)
Even in the rarified atmosphere that is Silicon Valley, the Instagram acquisition was unusual. Very much so. Acquired by Facebook just prior to their IPO. Lots of motivations for that, but by no means is Instagram an exemplar of anything. It's probably an outlier among outliers.
Re:Snapchat Is Mulling Another Huge Round at a $3.5 Billion ... by vidar on Friday October 25, 2013 @03:54PM (#6614100)
They were not about to ipo
Re:Snapchat Is Mulling Another Huge Round at a $3.5 Billion ... by brimanning on Friday October 25, 2013 @06:01PM (#6614951)
Not sure if you meant Instagram was not about to IPO, but rexreed meant Facebook was about to IPO (acquisition: April 14th, 2012, IPO: May 18th, 2012).
Re:Snapchat Is Mulling Another Huge Round at a $3.5 Billion ... by rexreed on Saturday October 26, 2013 @09:57PM (#6620444)
Exactly - Facebook was about to IPO and acquired Instagram pretty much right before it. Thanks for posting the dates to clarify.
Re:Snapchat Is Mulling Another Huge Round at a $3.5 Billion ... by andrewhillman on Friday October 25, 2013 @03:46PM (#6614056)
Nobody believed Twitter would make massive $ two years in. There's never been a startup who achieved serious traction but wasn't able to monetize itself.
Re:Snapchat Is Mulling Another Huge Round at a $3.5 Billion ... by jimboyoungblood on Friday October 25, 2013 @05:22PM (#6614732)
There's never been a startup who achieved serious traction but wasn't able to monetize itself.

You're joking, right?

Re:Snapchat Is Mulling Another Huge Round at a $3.5 Billion ... by andrewhillman on Friday October 25, 2013 @05:58PM (#6614935)
Not joking. If you know of any please share. To clarify, I am talking about consumer plays here.
Re:Snapchat Is Mulling Another Huge Round at a $3.5 Billion ... by loganfrederick on Friday October 25, 2013 @10:07PM (#6615935)
Digg, Friendster, MySpace just off the top of my head.
Re:Snapchat Is Mulling Another Huge Round at a $3.5 Billion ... by _delirium on Friday October 25, 2013 @10:08PM (#6615937)
It's a bit of a counterfactual, because startups with large traction having difficulty monetizing don't typically go bankrupt, but sell. But that doesn't prove they wouldn't have been able to monetize at some point, and leaves us guessing.

One example is YouTube; they lost huge buckets of money in their entire independent existence, until Google's acquisition completely changed the economics of their bandwidth costs. Would they have been able to become profitable if they stayed independent? Maybe!

Another one (perhaps clearer) is Broadcast.com. Never turned a profit in their independent existence; never turned a profit for Yahoo after acquisition, either.

Re:Snapchat Is Mulling Another Huge Round at a $3.5 Billion ... by 001sky on Friday October 25, 2013 @10:53PM (#6616053)
It's a bit of a counterfactual, because startups with large traction having difficulty monetizing don't typically go bankrupt, but sell

Interesting side or foot-note was that myspace went from 600m to 50m, first purchases (enabling vcs to exit) and then disposed of (by its BigCo purhaser) after not monetizing.

Re:Snapchat Is Mulling Another Huge Round at a $3.5 Billion ... by andrewhillman on Saturday October 26, 2013 @12:40AM (#6616371)
Digg, Myspace, BitTorrent, etc... at varying degrees were all able to monetize users and made millions upon millions of dollars while doing so. In fact, this answer from the founder of BitTorrent is to my point.

http://www.quora.com/How-profitable-is-BitTorrent-Inc

"Our main source of revenue is off the toolbars we push out, which isn't a great source of monetization, but it's something. You can do the math on how many installs we have and what the monetization of toolbars is, and subtract out the costs of having 50 employees, and you'll get a reasonable ballpark of how profitable we are, although the short answer is very. Even lousy monetization works well when you have more users than Twitter."

Re:Snapchat Is Mulling Another Huge Round at a $3.5 Billion ... by jimboyoungblood on Saturday October 26, 2013 @12:21AM (#6616325)
ChatRoulette, Napster, BitTorrent, PointCast, RockYou, etc etc
Re:Snapchat Is Mulling Another Huge Round at a $3.5 Billion ... by mh- on Friday October 25, 2013 @08:49PM (#6615722)
I'll +1 this if I can add the stipulation that it's a US-focused b2c play, mostly because I don't know the international space well.