Re:The Man Who Would Teach Machines to Think
by cgh on Thursday October 24, 2013 @06:39PM
(#6608517)
GEB's purpose wasn't to provide a comprehensive understanding of Godel's proofs. Nor was it trying to explain AI. It was a very personal book of thinking about thinking, basically. If you aren't a native English speaker then the book might have been less effective.
I own the Nagel and Newman book and probably read it every two years or so.
I also own the FARG book which summarises the work of the Fluid Analogies group. I don't think these papers are as interesting or exhilarating as GEB so I have to disagree with you there.
Re:The Man Who Would Teach Machines to Think
by carbocation on Thursday October 24, 2013 @02:07PM
(#6606819)
I don't agree with your dismissal of the work, but this is a very constructive comment on the whole with many interesting references and should not have been downvoted.
Re:The Man Who Would Teach Machines to Think
by giardini on Thursday October 24, 2013 @02:39PM
(#6607057)
I added the references later so that's the cause for down voting.
I didn't really dismiss the book: I read it attentively in it's entirety and, as anyone who has read it knows, that is a big book. But in the end I found nothing new or thought-provoking. Entertaining, yes; enlightening, no. "Where's the beef?" came to mind over and over as I moved through the text.
Hofstadter is certainly bright, has a voluminous memory and can be an entertaining writer but GEB is not IMO a contribution to AI. My expectations were undoubtedly too high.
If you want to understand Godel's proofs then I recommend the book "Godel's Proof" by Ernest Nagel and James R. Newman:
http://www.amazon.com/Gödels-Proof-Ernest-Nagel/dp/081475837...
Instead of Hofstadter's GEB, read some of his papers, e.g., "Analogy as the Core of Cognition" http://prelectur.stanford.edu/lecturers/hofstadter/analogy.h...
But there are others who have focused longer on analogy, e.g., George Lakoff:
"Metaphors we Live by"
http://www.amazon.com/Metaphors-We-Live-George-Lakoff/dp/022...
"Where Mathematics Come From: How The Embodied Mind Brings Mathematics Into Being":
http://www.amazon.com/Where-Mathematics-Come-Embodied-Brings...
"Women, Fire, and Dangerous Things"
http://www.amazon.com/Women-Fire-Dangerous-Things-Lakoff/dp/...