News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re: Google breaks 2005 promise never to show banner ads on s... by TheCraiggers on Thursday October 24, 2013 @11:28AM (#6605804)
If I search for MLK, I see his picture on the side. I don't see how getting a picture of Southwest Airlines when I search for "Southwest Airlines" is that big of a deal.

Now, if I were to search for "airlines" and saw that huge banner up there, I'd call that an ad and I'd be right there, handing out pitchforks. This? This is just returning searching results in a (arguably) prettier way.

Re: Google breaks 2005 promise never to show banner ads on s... by drhayes9 on Thursday October 24, 2013 @11:48AM (#6605905)
It's a big deal because this is a false equivalence. A corporation with a marketing budget and a brand is not the same as an historical figure. I think that explains a lot of the leeriness around this move.

That said, I'm leaning towards your interpretation ("search results in a prettier way"). But the money involved makes me nervous.

Re: Google breaks 2005 promise never to show banner ads on s... by chc on Thursday October 24, 2013 @01:17PM (#6606510)
Lots of people have an irrational fear of money. But in reality, money itself is rarely a problem.
Re: Google breaks 2005 promise never to show banner ads on s... by drhayes9 on Thursday October 24, 2013 @02:25PM (#6606953)
Sure. It's not money itself, per se, but the concurrent corruption it brings.
Re: Google breaks 2005 promise never to show banner ads on s... by socillion on Thursday October 24, 2013 @12:24PM (#6606132)
You're saying that whether or not it's advertising depends on the context of where the paid ad appears, which is an arbitrary and baseless distinction.

If a company rents a billboard that's right outside their office, isn't that advertising? Sure, you could have looked at the front of the building to see their logo, but that doesn't change the fact that the billboard is advertising.

Re: Google breaks 2005 promise never to show banner ads on s... by TheCraiggers on Thursday October 24, 2013 @01:52PM (#6606727)
I disagree with your analogy. In your case, I would say the banner represents the giant logo over the door, just before you walk into the building.

In most ad-based marketing, you're typically not just randomly throwing your brand out there. Obviously, the expected ROI goes up when you can target the right demographic (saturday morning cartoons versus world news with Tom Brokaw). This is not that. This isn't a demographic-driven ad, based on search criteria like "airline travel" or "buy tickets from DEN to DTW". The person knew exactly what they were searching for. Hell, depending on your browser, typing that exact string in your address bar will take you directly to Southwest Airlines. Google just managed to convince companies to pay them for this, while at the same time presenting a prettier and more useful direct links within that box.

As an afterthought, the most-searched for term in our company web portal is "google". I would be extremely surprised if Google, themselves, don't have a ton of searches where they could simply append a ".com" to the search query and send them directly to where they wanted. I doubt my parents would even notice.

Re: Google breaks 2005 promise never to show banner ads on s... by snowwrestler on Thursday October 24, 2013 @12:18PM (#6606102)
The difference is that Google does not charge MLK to have his info show up in knowledge graph results. As I understand it, they are charging Southwest Airlines for this big banner.

If it was just a larger knowledge graph box I doubt anyone would care.