If you had read really short article, the "next question" is: "To not mislead us about what he has read in the leaked NSA documents."
> I trust Bruce Schneier to not sacrifice his own principles and belief system in backdooring some code or otherwise compromising his work.
To mislead would be to compromise his own work.
As much as we all might respect Bruce we should remain reasonably open to the idea that he can be wrong (maliciously or otherwise). In essence, we shouldn't let a single expert, now matter how good they appear to be, become a single point of failure in our understanding of a complex subject.
It is open source. You are free to inspect it and see if it has backdoors.
Likewise with Twofish: https://www.schneier.com/twofish.html
This is quite the long con if you think he's been developing, advocating and promoting free (as in speech) software for years just in case this NSA thing got out of hand.
I agree we shouldn't let a single expert become a single point of failure in our understanding of security, but that's missing the point in this discussion. Based on Schneier's long history of work, including advocating open source solutions, he's earned my trust, but the great thing is that because he's such an advocate for open source, you can check the code. Likewise, if you're reading something he's written, you can check his sources. You don't have to trust him. You can do your own fact checking!
Do you breathe? Wait -- breathe what? Is the sky blue? Which sky? Where? Let's define our terms! Was this message written in English or are you misreading fluent Alienese?
Trust is the inverse of what most people think it is.
Trust isn't about what someone won't do, it's about what they will do.
You might trust a guy with your life by asking him to hold a ladder whilst you climb up it, but you probably wouldn't trust the same guy with your medical history and insights into your state of mind and personal relationships.
Yet you would trust a doctor with your medical history, and you would trust a psychiatrist with your mental wellbeing.
The basis of trust is a belief that the person/entity you are trusting will do something. In the case of that ladder, that the guy will hold it. In the case of the physician and psychiatrist that they will keep your information private. The NSA stuff can be seen in that light, there is a betrayal of trust as the basis for trust in a government spy agency was that they would do a certain thing... spy only on foreign people. The rest is all forgiveable (you pretty much should expect them to spy on everyone else whether you agree with it or not, that's their purpose).
When it comes to Bruce Schneier the question is "Do you trust Bruce Schneier?", but this seems to just beg the next question, "To do what?".
I trust Bruce Schneier to honor his own principles and belief system by not backdooring some code or otherwise compromising his work.
But I don't necessarily trust Bruce Schneier to hold a ladder that I'm standing on (he may well have a sense of humour that reflects silent cinema, and being up a ladder was never a good thing when a Loki character was holding it).
"I trust he WON'T let go of the ladder."
That's the same as
"I trust he WILL keep the ladder secured."
I'd say trust isn't about what you think the person won't do. It's about the person living up to their word or implied contract. It can be phrased either as a will do or a won't do.
Ladder guy holding it implies he will hold it securely. Doctor with private info implies he WON'T share it irresponsibly. That could also be worded as an expectation that he WILL keep it private.
"I trust Bruce Schneier to not sacrifice his own principles and belief system in backdooring some code or otherwise compromising his work."
OR
"I trust Bruce Schneier to be true to his principles and belief systems and maintain the integrity of his work."
The Bruce Schneier you know wouldn't compromise his own principles and beliefs but what if the Bruce Schneier you know isn't real? What if those principles and beliefs never existed?
Now we see why faith is requisite for living.
Luckily there's a book that does that. Liars and Outliers: Enabling the Trust that Society Needs to Thrive
http://www.amazon.com/Liars-Outliers-Enabling-Society-ebook/...
I would argue that we "know" Bruce Schneier from his writings and his works better than we know our doctors. The reason we "trust" our doctors is the implied and understood restrictions on sharing confidential medical data and not the character or works of the individuals (since we don't really know them).
With the NSA, that implied restriction (Constitution, laws) has been breached.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Loki
He's frequently referred to as the `God of Mischief` in that he's a trickster and capricious by nature.
Trust is the inverse of what most people think it is.
Trust isn't about what someone will do, it's about what they won't do.
You might trust a guy with your life by asking him to hold a ladder whilst you climb up it, but you probably wouldn't trust the same guy with your medical history and insights into your state of mind and personal relationships.
Yet you would trust a doctor with your medical history, and you would trust a psychiatrist with your mental wellbeing.
The basis of trust is a belief that the person/entity you are trusting won't do something. In the case of that ladder, that the guy won't let go. In the case of the physician and psychiatrist that they won't share information about you.
The NSA stuff can be seen in that light, there is a betrayal of trust as the basis for trust in a government spy agency was that they wouldn't do a certain thing... spy on their own people. The rest is all forgiveable (you pretty much should expect them to spy on everyone else whether you agree with it or not, that's their purpose).
When it comes to Bruce Schneier the question is "Do you trust Bruce Schneier?", but this seems to just beg the next question, "To not do what?".
I trust Bruce Schneier to not sacrifice his own principles and belief system in backdooring some code or otherwise compromising his work.
But I don't necessarily trust Bruce Schneier to hold a ladder that I'm standing on (he may well have a sense of humour that reflects silent cinema, and being up a ladder was never a good thing when a Loki character was holding it).