News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:iPad Air by phaus on Tuesday October 22, 2013 @02:26PM (#6593940)
So their new commercial for the iPad focuses on the fact that so many people use it for productivity, so why can't Apple create a decent, first-party pressure sensitive stylus, so we don't have to deal with expensive, clunky, third-party solutions.
Re:iPad Air by etchalon on Tuesday October 22, 2013 @07:27PM (#6595711)
There are quite a few third-party styli available for purchase. Apple doesn't want to include one because they don't want developers assuming the user has a stylus, and thus, crafting interfaces that require that level of precision. The iPad/iOS is about touch.

If the argument is that Apple should build one, but not include it by default, specifically for people who need one, I guess the response is "Why bother?"

Re:iPad Air by m_mueller on Wednesday October 23, 2013 @04:52AM (#6597663)
A stylus for a capacitive touch screen needs to be deeply integrated to work well - i.e. it needs some sensors along with the screen to anchor its position, simply because capacitive screen don't work well with pointy counterparts. That's why the stylus of MS surface is way better than any third party solution for iPad as far as I understand.

IMO Apple should integrate appropriate sensors and release an API for stylus makers or create it as an accessory themselves. I've bought two iPads since its initial release, and they work very well for me for some light browsing, but in order to integrate it into my workflow it'd have to become better at note taking.

I loved the MS Courier concept, it's too bad they instead created a solution that does everything, but nothing really well - you can either have desktop OneNote that only works with a stylus or mobile OneNote with nowhere near the features you'd need. Apple's iPad apps tend to have exactly the features you need except stylus support - so there's that.

Re:iPad Air by arbitrage on Tuesday October 22, 2013 @03:24PM (#6594233)
Obviously because Apple does not want you to use a stylus with it. Or perhaps, they don't want to be the ones to tell you that you could use a stylus with it if you wanted. They want to perpetuate the idea that it's self contained; a stylus would contradict that.
Re:iPad Air by JohnTHaller on Wednesday October 23, 2013 @08:32AM (#6598297)
The iPad doesn't have the same finger+stylus sensor tech that other tablets like the Samsung and Microsoft ones have. A real stylus simply won't work on an iPad because the iPad lacks the technology. So, as much as Apple says the iPad is for creative productivity, you won't find professionals using it like this: http://www.penny-arcade.com/2013/02/22/the-ms-surface-pro
Re:iPad Air by DonPellegrino on Tuesday October 22, 2013 @04:10PM (#6594587)
Jobs was strongly against the stylus and famously said something like "God gave us 10 styluses at birth". Maybe part of his legacy is a company filled with people having the same opinion.
Re:iPad Air by phaus on Tuesday October 22, 2013 @05:12PM (#6595016)
Steve Jobs isn't working at Apple anymore. He was great for Apple, but they aren't obligated to agree with every idea that he ever had, and integrate them into their business model.

He has often said that he thought something was stupid. More often than not, at the time he said these things, he was right. He once disliked the entire idea of the tablet, because the technology hadn't matured enough to deliver a positive experience for the customer. Long after he criticized tablets, he introduced the iPad to the world. It doesn't mean he's a hypocrite, it just means that the technology matured enough to change his mind.

Its hard to argue that Wacom technology isn't sufficiently mature, and there is clearly a market for such a thing. Art and note-taking apps are wildly popular. Both would be significantly enhanced by the presence of a true touch-sensitive stylus.

Apple didn't intend for the iPad to be a content creation device, but now they seem to be embracing it as such, because that's what many customers want to do with it.

If a person never changes his mind about anything, that person has stopped learning.

Re:iPad Air by nooneelse on Tuesday October 22, 2013 @05:10PM (#6595001)
Yeah, and we learn to finger-paint very early, it being quite intuitive and all... but then we grow up and the overwhelming majority of people learn to use writing implements (and other such tools of numerous sorts). I haven't been able, nor wanted to, turn in finger-painted work since early elementary school. Adults use pens (and other such) to write, as well they should, since doing so increases the efficiency of complex output from mind to page.
Re:iPad Air by misuba on Tuesday October 22, 2013 @08:23PM (#6595948)
And the iPad is growing up too, and can extend itself into new kinds of usage with new, _supplementary_ kinds of input.
Re:iPad Air by enraged_camel on Tuesday October 22, 2013 @03:46PM (#6594415)
Steve Jobs said it best: "if you see a stylus, they blew it."
Re:iPad Air by 51Cards on Tuesday October 22, 2013 @04:05PM (#6594556)
That statement gets used a lot to downplay the concept of a stylus, and in that context it is flatly incorrect to be blunt. Viewing it that ways makes the assumption that you intent to use a stylus as a finger replacement. The finger and the stylus are different input devices with different levels of ease of use and accuracy. It is wrong to assume they are meant to accomplish the same tasks. No device should be limited to either one... finger or stylus. I use the stylus to draw on my Surface and quite frankly I love what it allows me to do. But when I go back to surfing, fingers all the way.
Re:iPad Air by fumar on Tuesday October 22, 2013 @04:41PM (#6594814)
Lets pretend paper is the leading technology for communication. The leader in the paper industry thinks you should write/draw with your finger. You have ten of them.

But, some people, need more precision than a human finger allows. They use an object with a finer point than our fingers. But, the rest of us are okay with just finger painting. The paper was designed to be large enough for fingers to use.

It would be nice to sometimes use a different input method on paper when the finger won't cut it. I see nothing wrong with having more than one input method. There is no right or wrong way.

Re:iPad Air by biot on Tuesday October 22, 2013 @04:25PM (#6594706)
Steve Jobs also said you'd have to sharpen your fingers to use a tablet smaller than the full-sized iPad. :)
Re:iPad Air by oftenwrong on Tuesday October 22, 2013 @05:12PM (#6595023)
Maybe Steve Jobs was wrong.

Ship it without a stylus. Require that all apps be usable with fingers. Make a sweet pressure-sensitive stylus available for extra precision. Everyone wins.

Re:iPad Air by elliotanderson on Tuesday October 22, 2013 @09:28PM (#6596144)
Plenty of third parties already filling that space - I don't think Apple sees the need to move in that direction.
Re:iPad Air by phaus on Tuesday October 22, 2013 @09:50PM (#6596251)
They are doing a piss poor job of filling that space because all they can do is work within the limitations of the capacitive touch screen and/or the wireless capabilities of the device. If Apple implemented a proper digitizer, it would be far better than any third party solution.
Re:iPad Air by theguycalledtom on Tuesday October 22, 2013 @09:36PM (#6596187)
He was talking about driving the interface. The iPad has been designed from the ground up with capactive touch so that you can navigate an iPad with your fingers. Adding a pen digitiser changes nothing.
Re:iPad Air by misuba on Tuesday October 22, 2013 @08:19PM (#6595937)
For core usage he was right, but: I'll bet you Steve owned a pen. I'll bet you it was great. And I'll bet you he used it a lot.
Re:iPad Air by jasonlotito on Tuesday October 22, 2013 @10:50PM (#6596499)
Steve Jobs also said you'd write your apps for the iPhone using JavaScript. Or that you don't need multitasking.

Here's the thing, it's not the stylus that is the problem. It's the dependency on a stylus. There is a difference between doing it, and doing it right.

Re:iPad Air by hippee-lee on Wednesday October 23, 2013 @04:04AM (#6597508)
I would wager that Steve Jobs was not very interested in drawing or painting. I'll bet he would understand someone who was into drawing and painting who used a stylus, especially a pressure sensitive stylus.
Re:iPad Air by snowwrestler on Tuesday October 22, 2013 @04:57PM (#6594925)
Why do you think that an Apple stylus would be any less expensive or clunky?
Re:iPad Air by phaus on Tuesday October 22, 2013 @05:00PM (#6594942)
Because every other tablet pc/tablet with a integrated pressure-sensitive stylus is much better than anything released thus far for the iPad by third parties.
Re:iPad Air by snowwrestler on Tuesday October 22, 2013 @05:26PM (#6595115)
Samsung and Microsoft license Wacom digitizer technology for their stylus tablets. It's not just that they provide a stylus--the tablet itself has additional capacitive sensors. Apple would have to totally re-engineer their touch sensor to accomodate that.

The reason iPad styluses have fat tips is that they have to simulate a fingertip, which is the only thing that an iPad can sense. The tradeoff is that an iPad is faster and more accurate at sensing fingers than other tablets.

Wacom has released a pressure-sensitive stylus for iPad. I have not tried it though...not much of an artist.

Re:iPad Air by gjm11 on Tuesday October 22, 2013 @07:34PM (#6595742)
> the tablet itself has additional capacitive sensors.

Inductive, actually, which is why the stylus doesn't need to have a big fat tip.

Wacom also make a stylus for the iPad, which obviously has to be capacitive rather than inductive. I think it has batteries in it and sends tip pressure information to the iPad over Bluetooth.

(How the inductive sensing works: You have some conductive loops behind the display, and in the pen there is a ferrite rod with a conductive coil around it together with a capacitor to make a resonant circuit. You pass an alternating current at approximately the resonant frequency through some of the loops; it couples to the pen circuit by electromagnetic induction, the pen circuit resonates, and for a short time it produces, by induction again, a signal in all the other conducting coils behind the display. How much signal depends on the position and angle of the coil in the pen. If you have enough loops behind the display you can work out where the pen tip is accurately enough to draw with it. The capacitor in the resonant circuit is variable and adjusted by the tip pressure, and small changes in the resonant frequency produce phase changes in the signal that comes back, so you can measure the tip pressure too. Similar technology is used in some interactive whiteboards.)

Re:iPad Air by phaus on Tuesday October 22, 2013 @05:59PM (#6595270)
The digitizer is actually a separate layer in most cases. There are lots of products that have both a digitizer and a capacitive touch layer. The lack of a digitizer isn't what makes the iPad more responsive. If Apple wanted to do it, it would be trivial.

Wacom fucked up this particular product, because they opted to use a large rubber tip. It might be more precise than a normal dumb stylus, but its still terrible. Trying to write like a normal person, or draw thin lines is absolutely horrible with a fat-tipped stylus.

Re:iPad Air by snowwrestler on Tuesday October 22, 2013 @06:07PM (#6595323)
I think the large rubber tip is not optional, as the iPad sensor is looking for a particular shape: a fingertip.
Re:iPad Air by phaus on Tuesday October 22, 2013 @06:50PM (#6595528)
Right. It was never debatable whether or not the current iPad has a digitizer. It doesn't. I'm just saying if they are starting to embrace productivity, they should have added one.

The current iPad has a capacitive touch screen, that's why the current styli use a large tip, the stylus isn't replicating a pen, its replicating a fingertip. That's why they all suck. Its hard to write / draw with your finger, so until we stop making styli that replicate fingers, note taking and drawing on the iPad are going to be suboptimal.