As this was second tier, I wouldn't really call it "search" traffic. Just a ton of users with keyword-like queries being routed to various xml feeds/exchanges. When we'd send the traffic to actual publishers with conversion goals the rates were abysmal and we'd end up issuing lots of refunds. The only publishers that seemed to like the traffic were ones that sold their own dedicated ad units to large brand advertisers.
I'm just glad to be out of that industry :)
When there's money and success at stake, it's difficult to be too cynical about what tactics are probably being employed.
Possible, but not much value for an arbitrage savvy publisher.
Not going to name names, but a good deal of fuckery is afoot in under article link exchange widgets. You know the ones, the boxes with link bait thumbnails that show up on a good deal of popular entertainment sites. Dealt with a lot of fake traffic coming through from the link exchange network. It appeared other publishers were sending tons of fake bot clicks to our site, in order to give themselves a higher amount of free reciprocal traffic from the link exchange.
It's worth remembering that sites like comScore, Quantcast, Alexa and Hitwise derive a solid chunk of their business by enabling Google sales reps to better convince clients to spend more money. It's not far off from an academic whose career depends on grants by parties who are heavily invested in seeing a particular outcome.
The thing is a lot of publishers are fully aware of the fact that the traffic is mostly fraudulent. The ones who rely on bogus metrics such as Quantcast, Hitwise, Comscore, Alexa, etc. They buy up a ton of second tier search traffic for extremely low PPCs, we're talking sub-penny, and use that to inflate their "visitors" metric which is then used to sell how popular their site is to large brand advertisers.