News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Review of the DSM-V as a piece of dystopian fiction by andrewcooke on Saturday October 19, 2013 @11:24PM (#6578837)
then fix those, but don't throw the baby out with the bathwater.

the problem is that, at least in my case, DSM-V was replaced with an appeal to authority.

when the alternative is "ok boss, you know best" i prefer a list of symptoms where i can argue, "look, almost anyone could tick half these boxes at some point in their lives". at least i can see what's happening.

i am not saying that DSM-V is a rule book that should be followed blindly. i am not saying that it is "right", or that it carries some kind of moral weight. all that i am saying is that any communication - even dissent - needs a common vocabulary, and DSM-V can provide that.

from my outside perspective it seems that it's a tool; that the real problem is some of the doctors. discarding the tool won't improve the bad doctors, it will just make them less accountable. how is that an improvement?

Re:Review of the DSM-V as a piece of dystopian fiction by harvestmoon on Sunday October 20, 2013 @01:59PM (#6580756)
You seem to not realize that the DSM-5 can be used to justify treating you with a wide variety of medications.

If you feel a little down, occasionally feel a bit energized and happy, and sometimes anxious, using the DSM 5 your shrink can gladly give you:

antidepressants antipsychotics anxiety medications

and more.

Re:Review of the DSM-V as a piece of dystopian fiction by andrewcooke on Sunday October 20, 2013 @02:42PM (#6580931)
doctors can do what they want anyway. getting rid of DSM-V won't remove those powers. it just removes a way to describe / discuss (and perhaps challenge) what they are doing. so you're actually making things more open to abuse.

but i'm not sure if this will help explain things, as i thought my comment above was pretty clear anyway.