News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Review of the DSM-V as a piece of dystopian fiction by DanBC on Saturday October 19, 2013 @08:51PM (#6578572)
> but he then diagnosed me with something and prescribed me a drug. when i asked why, he said i should trust his intuition

DSM or no, too many doctors prescribe medication off-label. People with one of the personality disorders get a diagnosis and then some semi-random medication with some experimental[1] psychotherapy. All the clinicians disagree about what the treatment should be, but they see that as a feature of the patient's illness. Thus, if the patient is doing exactly what Dr A wants (but not what Dr B wants) Dr B will say it's the patient's manipulation which is part of the illness, and not that it's just a conflict among the team

I'm not sure how it works in the US, but some psychiatric diagnoses can be used to detain a person in hospital against their will. There's no court process, no judge. There are some protections, but these are not great.

Re:Review of the DSM-V as a piece of dystopian fiction by mjn on Saturday October 19, 2013 @08:59PM (#6578595)
On the latter part, this is pretty rare now in the US. Involuntary "holds" are almost always short-term, and only initiated when there's some disturbance that results in the police being called. In California, for example, a 72-hour hold is the most common, although 2-week and longer holds are possible: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/5150_(involuntary_psychiatric_h...

The downside is that the old system of involuntary commitment, which I do believe civil-liberties campaigners were right to campaign against, has not really been replaced with anything. Some proportion of those who were previously involuntarily committed are better off, living some kind of life, whether a normal one, or some kind of bohemian one, or with family, or otherwise getting by. But some proportion are a mixture of homeless and in and out of jail or 72-hour holds, without any serious long-term attempt to do anything about their situation. Especially true if either they lack close family, or lack family with enough means to take them in, or have psychotic episodes that their family finds threatening. A schizophrenic guy I know through the tech scene is in that category; has been 72-hour held 4 or 5 times, on a 2-week hold once, arrested for various kinds of minor disturbances a dozen times, etc., but never received much treatment, except during the short periods of psychiatric confinement.

Re:Review of the DSM-V as a piece of dystopian fiction by cloverich on Saturday October 19, 2013 @09:03PM (#6578604)
Varies from state to state, http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Involuntary_commitment#United_S...

I did a 6-week rotation in a psych ward for exclusively psychotic patients ( mostly schizophrenic, some manic). I can't recall if they were all held specifically for being a danger to themselves / others, but remember court orders being regularly obtained (and always required) and then only for patients who were very psychotic (medically psychotic --> delusional, typically to the point of being unable to function).