This pseudo argument is akin to those who, after some initial evidence came to light about the harmful effects of smoking 50-60 years ago, argued that with a filter, smoking was safe (because the filter would 'catch' the bad stuff).
No matter what kind of technique or equipment you use, nothing will 100% prevent the escape of the carcinogenic compounds produced by the chemical reaction of burning wood.
So the question becomes, do you want a little bit of carcinogens in your air? a lot of them? or none (produced by you in your enclosed space/home)?
So my point regarding this article, you cannot draw risk conclusion without comparing the various combustion techniques.
I have burned wood in a highly inefficient, toxic way to heat my home, as I only had an inappropriate furnace. To put things into perspective, in our town, the junkyard is essentially perpetually smoldering, giving off quite potent fumes.
When burned properly, both wood and many types of garbage should not create carcinogens, I think. Burning typical coal releases uranium, which will be radioactive, unless you scrub it, put it in a nuclear reactor or so.
Inefficient fires don't get as hot and cause more smoke. efficient fires get much hotter, and have better airflow. These burn more "stuff", and it burns cleaner.
An identical argument can be made about wireless radiation. Literally, do a search/replace of a lot of the quackery throughout this whole discussion and you've got a standard discussion about banning wifi.
e.g. I have heard that standing close to a high power transmitter is dangerous. Therefore, I am in danger because of my neighbour's wifi transmitter.
Now someone is going to argue about ionizing potential energy, but the same principals apply for carcinogenic compounds, which are literally all around us. The process of cooking almost invariably even creates new carcinogenic compounds -- do you eschew cooking?
Reductionism is almost always garbage science if taken holistically (it has value within a context, however). Are there actual demonstrated correlative studies of recreational burn "advocates"? Of neighbours? Do wildfires lead to mass outbreaks of cancer (or even a statistically discernable incident rates)? No? Then it sounds like an enormous reach of extraterritorial offense.
They are high power variants of their low power cousins. The latter isn't dangerous simply as a factor of magnitude. But the same arguments apply. Further it's an interesting note that the classification of something as a carcinogen usually is arrived at via very large levels of exposure, and there are endless tables of "acceptable" exposure to such carcinogenic materials.
This fireplace issue would seem to be something that would be studied to death, and strong correlative findings demonstrating a sound case (given how utterly dire and extreme the submission is). Instead you get things like this-
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3002194/
I'll skip to the fun part -- wood burning homes did have more incidents of cancer, because they had a higher correlation with smokers (similar to how, for instance, blue jeans probably have a higher incidence of cancer than khakis). Among non-smokers the incident rates of cancer are absolutely identical with non wood burning homes. Isn't that incredible, and doesn't that simply destroy the submission? And this is for frequent users who use it as a primary source of fuel, so a level of exposure dramatically higher than such a recreational user.
http://www.hc-sc.gc.ca/hl-vs/iyh-vsv/environ/wood-bois-eng.p...