Second Life has no intrinsic value that I can see. Twitter does; it's persistant, searchable, real-time communication.
SL could be a pretty good playground. I would have liked to create games for it. I guess stuff like the alife island (forgot the name) were pretty cool, too. A lot of creativity took place.
A couple of days I logged into SL again, and the only places with people in them seemed to be the escort services :-( (I looked at the map and just zoomed into places with many people present, and they always were escort agencies, I think).
Hope Twitter won't see the same fate - their "recommended users to follow" thing is definitely not cutting it yet. Then again, for the mainstream users, some starlets to follow might be just the thing.