Re:To an alarming degree, science is not self-correcting
by dekhn on Friday October 18, 2013 @10:05AM
(#6571408)
Even positive results aren't always convincing when they go against the scientific mainstream. For example, consider the
Avery/Macleod experiment that showed genes and chromosomes (and thus the heredity) were made of DNA- positive result, easy to analyze the methods and results- and frequently ignored.
It wasn't until the far simpler and more unambiguous experiment- that even physicists could understand- Hershey/Chase was done. But oddly, it was a negative result when it was published: "protein is not the heredity molecule" although by reasonable exclusion, one could easily conclude that DNA was almost certainly the heredity molecule.
Even then, a lot of other evidence was required for the mainstream community to accept this. Protein bias is long and exists today.
It wasn't until the far simpler and more unambiguous experiment- that even physicists could understand- Hershey/Chase was done. But oddly, it was a negative result when it was published: "protein is not the heredity molecule" although by reasonable exclusion, one could easily conclude that DNA was almost certainly the heredity molecule.
Even then, a lot of other evidence was required for the mainstream community to accept this. Protein bias is long and exists today.