News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Underworked American Child by caffeine on Saturday June 13, 2009 @10:02PM (#656706)
Something needs to be done to make the school year more worthwhile for such students

Actually, it needs to be done for ALL students. You really think the only kids poorly served by school are those that teach themselves math on the side?

Nearly every kid has an innate curiosity about the world and more importantly the people around him. Some prefer symbolic worlds, others the physical, and most the social.

Schools are currently poor places to learn about any of those. The bizarre hierarchies in place seriously warp most children - witness the daily cruelty that is normal in an average school (others on the internet have made this point better than I can).

To most people, Lockhart's lament is a very minor annoyance compared to the social retardation that goes on in these institutions. Rampant alcohol abuse and unreasonable sexual promiscuity in universities are the inevitable backlash to years of social repression, far beyond the young ages at which it might be called for.

It was not unreasonable in earlier times to consider someone a "young man" or "young woman" at 13 or 14, and as a fully functional society member at 16. Why does this seem so completely ludicrous now? Has our genetic lifecycle programming changed? Of course not - but our social lifecycle programming has.

All this to say that the kids for whom symbolic systems education is too slow are the lucky ones. For them, there is at least the library as an outlet for that spark. Consider the rest, who have no such thing.

Re:The Underworked American Child by spitfire on Sunday June 14, 2009 @12:05AM (#656793)
No.

Our world is a thousand times more complex than that of even the 1800's. It used to be that your average young man/woman was in one unskilled job for their entire life. One you could learn by the time you were 15-16. This is no longer the case.

Even entry level office jobs jobs now require an understanding of calculus, statistics, excel, etc. When all that used to be required was knowing how to plow a field, recite wives tales or run a loom.

It isn't as simple as "oh our education system is too slow".

Re:The Underworked American Child by apsec112 on Sunday June 14, 2009 @03:25AM (#656915)
"Even entry level office jobs jobs now require an understanding of calculus, statistics, excel, etc."

This is simply not true. Entry-level office jobs require a piece of paper saying "this dude knows calculus"; they don't actually require the knowledge. If you don't believe me, visit an average office, go around, and ask people to take the derivative of sin(x)*x^2; this is a fairly simple problem which any first-semester calculus student would know how to solve.

Re:The Underworked American Child by DougBTX on Sunday June 14, 2009 @07:37AM (#657027)
Perhaps you meant sin(x)+x^2?
Re:The Underworked American Child by sketerpot on Sunday June 14, 2009 @03:35PM (#657458)
No. Just use the product rule. The derivative is

x^2 cos(x) + 2 x sin(x)

Finding derivatives is actually really easy. There are just a few simple rules you have to apply deterministically to any problem, and the answer will pop out.

Re:The Underworked American Child by jrockway on Monday June 15, 2009 @01:30AM (#657999)
I think his point was to suggest a simpler question. Do you really think most "entry-level office workers" remember the product rule?
Re:The Underworked American Child by sketerpot on Monday June 15, 2009 @02:31AM (#658034)
I believe the whole point of proposing a calculus question was that most entry-level office workers won't be able to answer it.
Re:The Underworked American Child by jrockway on Monday June 15, 2009 @02:35AM (#658037)
As I mention above, I bet they wouldn't be able to answer an even simpler question. Requiring application of product rule "raises the bar" a bit too high.
Re:The Underworked American Child by jrockway on Monday June 15, 2009 @01:29AM (#657997)
I'm not sure why this is modded down so far, as it raises a good point. If you ask the average entry-level office tech to differentiate x^2 with respect to x, it is likely that they will not even know that. Throw in the product rule, and all bets are off. (I am embarrassed to admit that I had to quickly look at MathWorld to make sure I hadn't misremembered it.)
Re:The Underworked American Child by callmeed on Sunday June 14, 2009 @03:22AM (#656914)
Show me an entry level office job posting/ad where calculus is a requirement ...
Re:The Underworked American Child by caffeine on Sunday June 14, 2009 @06:50AM (#657014)
You're missing the point.

Technical learning of any sort (looms or calculus) is really the least important consequence of schooling - if it takes 20 years, fine.

The fundamental error is to assume that socialization (for which nearly all humans are genetically optimized) and training in symbolic methods (for which most humans are rather ill-suited) should proceed apace.

Re:The Underworked American Child by quizbiz on Sunday June 14, 2009 @12:07AM (#656794)
Do you know how to run a loom or plow a field? Maybe oddly, but I consider those much more a skill than knowledge of how to use excel.
Re:The Underworked American Child by spitfire on Sunday June 14, 2009 @12:16AM (#656800)
Yes and yes. A loom is actually sort of neat. They're the first programable computers. A plow on the other hand is dull and difficult work.

Both are simpler than excel even for their more advanced uses.

Re:The Underworked American Child by ramidarigaz on Sunday June 14, 2009 @03:21AM (#656913)
I would say yes, the plow is much more simple than excel. However, I disagree that the loom is too. You can do amazing things with a loom if you take the time to learn the complexities of the machine.