Dylan lives somewhere pretty far from that dive site and there are a lot of other places where he could have harvested an octo. Instead of doing so, he chose a most popular dive site around, place well known for people coming to look at octopuses, came there during the day and killed one of the creatures. When somewhat exasperated divers ask him "Dude, WTF?" he told them that he was in his right and suggested to mind their own business.
Imagine a park somewhere, where it is well known that deer come and interact with people. There is a family playing with a nice baby deer here and then a hunter shows up, walks right to the deer, who is not afraid of people and cuts bambi's throat, right in front of the family. Yes, he is within his right to do it, but he behaved like a dick.
That's what started a shitstorm, not a desire to stop harvest of Octos. There is a lot of them in Puget Sound and they are not in any danger and divers know this. Just don't be a jackass and butcher a Bambi in a petting zoo.
Octopuses are intelligent. They are playful and awesome. You've seen the video of octopuses using coconut shells to hide in?
There comes a point when something is acting as if it is intelligent, or as if it has emotions, that it's reasonable to assume they are intelligent or they do have emotions. Not necessarily the same as ours, but on a spectrum.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1DoWdHOtlrk
http://news.nationalgeographic.com/news/2009/12/091214-octop...
> The coconut-carrying behavior makes the veined octopus the newest member of the elite club of tool-using animals—and the first member without a backbone, researchers say.
My father used to work with "looked after children" (Children in children's homes). He visited a home, and there was a boy there who had a pet crow. The boy had taught this crow some tricks, including holding a cigarette in its beak. (This would have been about 40 years ago.) My pa took a photo of the boy, and his pet crow, and the crow is "smoking". I have that photo still.
I think what I'm trying to say is that individuals have their own reasons for eating (or not eating) various animals, and so long as those people are not too preachy we can all get along. It is odd that societies tend to have differing views on acceptability of eating various animals - dogs are fine in some countries but not others, horse is tasty in France but weird in UK, Cows are sacred to some but delicious to others.
http://www.sefs.washington.edu/research.acl/Crows_and_Other_...
Then there's the "attractiveness" factor. If I killed a beautiful butterfly (heck, even if I extirpated a bed of tulips) I'd probably be labeled as a sociopath.
Which, of course, is why you should never smile at an angry dog.
This "dolphins play with bubble rings" video is ancient but great. Play is perhaps a tricky word, but still.
But calling an animal's behavior intelligent or playful is only anthropomorphizing if we know that playing and intelligence are unique to humans. Which we don't.
But maybe they're inflating the pig's intelligence because they don't want people to eat pigs?
If we weren't so keen on describing things involving humans as "unnatural", I think the relationship between humans and livestock animals would generally be seen as symbiotic (much like ants who farm fungus).
If you do a search for Alki GPO, from before the harvest, you can find that there were many divers who were able to get their underwater photography hobbies started with a picture of that GPO. This particular GPO was about as tame as any GPO that I've personally seen in the Puget Sound. This gave new divers a chance to take their time trying to get their cameras setup, as well as getting multiple pictures.
I think it's just social taboo.
Everyone defecates, and everyone is fine with that. However if you did that on a public beach, people would be outraged.
Also, if you beat up a cow, dog or bear with your bare hands on a beach, people would be outraged with that too.
I'm not sure that trying to come up with a "rational" way of looking at it makes sense. It makes people uncomfortable because it violates social norms.
You would have to frame the act in certain ways for people to be comfortable with it. If the Octopus was dangerous, for example. Or if you had some elaborate social ritual around killing it. Or if it was structured as your job, people knew you were going to do it humanely. Etc.
We have a diver who killed an animal for food, and this generated tremendous outrage. Why?
It's certainly not the bare fact that he killed an animal for food. That happens all the time, and people mostly don't care.
He ended up doing it in front of a crowd, but that's not the reason either. If he had killed, say, a trout in front of a crowd, nobody would really care.
Nor is it the kind of animal that he killed, not alone. If he had done it in private then told the public about what happened, there would have been no outcry.
Clearly it's some combination of the kind of animal and doing it in public. There's no particular reason either one should matter, though. There is, it appears, nothing particularly special about this animal that makes it a bad choice for food compared to other animals. But clearly it does matter.
I think it comes down to the simple fact that this was an unusual event. And though there was nothing specific about this event that should lead to outcry, the mere fact that it was unusual is enough. A lot of city dwellers are fundamentally uncomfortable with eating meat. Most of them still do it, but they hide behind the various structures that exist between the living animal and their dinner plate to kind of ignore it. I've heard of people seriously saying things like, "It's wrong to kill an animal for meat. You should just buy it from the grocery store." I'm sure most people are not that ignorant, but there's a similar sort of avoiding thinking about the stark reality of slaughtering and butchering.
So you have a bunch of people suddenly confronted with that which they try to ignore. Some of them are outraged by the mechanics of killing and eating an animal. But most of them still eat cows and pigs and chickens which are routinely killed in ways not really different from this. What reason could there be for their outrage, then? It can't be that they're outraged at the overall concept of killing an animal for food. But, ah hah! This is an unusual animal, so it must be that!
And that, I think, is how you end up with a conservation campaign for an animal that is not endangered and not, ultimately, all that special.
I could be way off, but it's interesting to think about.