News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Oracle releases 127 security fixes, 51 for Java alone by jeswin on Thursday October 17, 2013 @02:02AM (#6563889)
I was reading this FUD whitepaper just a while back, in which they are saying OSS is unsuitable for enterprises, unscalable, untested, insecure, etc. http://www.oracle.com/us/products/middleware/cloud-app-found...

And then this.

Re:Oracle releases 127 security fixes, 51 for Java alone by logn on Thursday October 17, 2013 @03:49AM (#6564120)
That whitepaper isn't really FUD. It's basically just explaining 'open source' to people who don't really get it. The paper explains that Oracle software includes open source software and then Oracle is arguing that they do a better job of developing, leveraging, integrating, and supporting FOSS than IT workers in gov't offices can. It's a fairly reasonable argument.
Re:Oracle releases 127 security fixes, 51 for Java alone by chrissmeuk on Thursday October 17, 2013 @05:12AM (#6564302)
I beg to differ. The UK government (finally) has got its act together in this department. We're seeing the NHS's core "Spine" system being rewritten using open source software (riak/erlang/ubuntu + others) and we have the excellent http://gov.uk/ as well.
Re:Oracle releases 127 security fixes, 51 for Java alone by CircusAct on Thursday October 17, 2013 @07:18AM (#6564622)
And then you have a look at the new Universal Credit scheme. Glad IT schemes to do with the NHS are improving though.
Re:Oracle releases 127 security fixes, 51 for Java alone by chrissmeuk on Thursday October 17, 2013 @07:32AM (#6564667)
Good point. I do however feel that the government departments that have failed miserably on projects will start looking at more successful projects for inspiration. We'll be a few more £billion down by then but things will improve.

HMRC's systems are pretty good these days as well (I just did my tax return online). Relatively smooth process for a large Java behemoth.

Re:Oracle releases 127 security fixes, 51 for Java alone by ksk on Thursday October 17, 2013 @08:55AM (#6565010)
You claim you read it, but they don't say that at all.

What they're specifically saying is that government is not the ideal entity to be shepherding OSS projects. More specifically - Large Scale OSS projects that require a rigorous process and are mission critical. They observe that OSS Projects exhibit high quality primarily (though not exclusively) when there is a large financial motive to make the project high quality. (E.g. Linux, Firefox, and the other big hits).

Now, Oracle might be against-OSS in general, but this paper is not the "FUD" that you're looking for.

Re:Oracle releases 127 security fixes, 51 for Java alone by jeswin on Thursday October 17, 2013 @09:22AM (#6565134)
The articles is littered with FUD:

1. Oracle is embracing and offering open source solutions as a viable way to complete simple software projects and as an adjunct to the development and deployment of more complex projects that are based on commercial software.

- Open source for tiny projects. Oracle for the real work. Got it.

2. Another key issue facing government acquisition executives is the issue of indemnification. When a software company provides a product to its customers, it is expected to stand by its product, and is legally required to do so. In the case of open source, there are remarkably few companies willing or able to offer indemnification for their “products.”

- There are several open source companies, which stand by their "products", and offer support contracts.

3. Load testing, system performance tuning, and system optimization are also expensive tasks. Commercial software companies have developed highly refined methodologies to perform these tasks.

- I've worked some with Oracle databases. Most organizations are paying through the nose for little benefit; management loves whitepapers like this.

4. Oracle licenses commercial software to fill the gaps where open source does not fully address enterprise capability requirements. Automated Deployment & Provisioning ...Extreme Performance, High Availability, & Scalability

- Ok.

5. If you are concerned with vendor lock-in, and you see open source solutions as a means of “owning” the code you want to run, a quick glance at the Open Source Initiative (OSI) can be daunting. Nearly 100 licensing regimes have gone through the license approval process. Open source is not free, nor is it easy to understand the strict legal terms and conditions associated with its use.

- I've found the popular OSS licenses quite simple to understand and there are excellent explanations available; Most Open Source apps use one of these, though there might be 100 which are OSI approved.

6. And finally, the biggest one. The VA story.

- https://yourlogicalfallacyis.com/anecdotal

Edit: OSI Licensing(5)

Re:Oracle releases 127 security fixes, 51 for Java alone by ksk on Thursday October 17, 2013 @10:09AM (#6565415)
First, lets address your original comments. These are your words "in which they are saying OSS is unsuitable for enterprises, unscalable, untested, insecure, etc.".

Your characterization implies that the main theme of the paper is "OSS is unsuitable for enterprises, unscalable, insecure, etc". Please find me a single line in the PDF YOU linked to that implies "OSS is unsuitable for enterprises, unscalable and insecure".

-------------------------

> And finally, the biggest one. The VA story. - https://yourlogicalfallacyis.com/anecdotal

How incredibly dishonest of you. You've presented all your evidence as simply your own assertions, experience and anecdotes. Where is YOUR data?

Lets examine your own words :-

>"There are several open source companies, which stand by their "products", and offer support contracts"

Several? How many? Out of how many in total? What contracts have you looked at? How do they compare to other contracts offered to DoD by non-open source companies?

>I've worked some with Oracle databases. Most organizations are paying through the nose for little benefit;

That is your experience and assertion. Why should anyone care? Are you a well known person in the database domain whose opinion is widely respected?

>I've found the popular OSS licenses quite simple to understand and there are excellent explanations available; Most Open Source apps use one of these, though there might be 100 which are OSI approved.

Okay so YOU have found them simple. Again why is your anectdote and experience so superior? Are you a well known licensing expert? --------------------

See, its rather easy to accuse someone of FUD, its another thing to actually provide evidence beyond some vague arguments. :)

Re:Oracle releases 127 security fixes, 51 for Java alone by chrissmeuk on Thursday October 17, 2013 @03:43AM (#6564107)
That whitepaper is for management and purchasing. The security patches are for the poor sysops who have to look after the mess left behind by the former.

Every large commercial software company is just as bad. It was only a few years ago that Microsoft were doing the same, until they realised they could monetize open source software themselves[1] as well and decided to stop the badmouthing.

[1] through azure and buying into major open source ecosystems to gain mindshare.