Re:The war on drugs is a broken business model
by smsm42 on Wednesday October 16, 2013 @07:52PM
(#6562812)
I agree with the last phrase, but probably not for the reason the author intends. I admit though I didn't read the article beyond the first page - and your quote, of course - as, frankly, it contained too much wrong from the start that I didn't want to waste any more of my time on it. Reading Ignatiev's profile, he certainly looks like a person way out of the mainstream and with good deal of cookiness in him, so I'm not sure he's a good example of a mainstream academic or writer.
I think also there is confusing equality of possibilities with equality of outcomes. The outcomes are demonstrably unequal. But is this because medical industry or welfare system are racial? From what I see, some systems are now geared to give unfair advantage to minority players willing to game the system (google "Pigford settlement"). However, as I said, the overall outcomes are still very unequal. I think there are institutional causes for it, but I think the causes are not racial now (though historically they were) but viewing it through exclusively racial lens today only makes it worse, as it makes people take wrong decisions (i.e. vote for corrupt and incompetent, but racially suitable politician, instead of honest and competent one of a wrong race). Same with regard to war on drugs - if we decide it's about racism, we should then spend our efforts on ensuring persons of all races are equally punished for equal crimes. Which is exactly wrong thing to do in this situation - instead we should spend our efforts on ensuring nobody is punished for something that should not be a crime in the first place!
I think also there is confusing equality of possibilities with equality of outcomes. The outcomes are demonstrably unequal. But is this because medical industry or welfare system are racial? From what I see, some systems are now geared to give unfair advantage to minority players willing to game the system (google "Pigford settlement"). However, as I said, the overall outcomes are still very unequal. I think there are institutional causes for it, but I think the causes are not racial now (though historically they were) but viewing it through exclusively racial lens today only makes it worse, as it makes people take wrong decisions (i.e. vote for corrupt and incompetent, but racially suitable politician, instead of honest and competent one of a wrong race). Same with regard to war on drugs - if we decide it's about racism, we should then spend our efforts on ensuring persons of all races are equally punished for equal crimes. Which is exactly wrong thing to do in this situation - instead we should spend our efforts on ensuring nobody is punished for something that should not be a crime in the first place!