Your first point is wrong as well. If insider trading were legal there would be a huge incentive for insiders to keep inside information away from the public. This would lead to slower dissemination of inside information. It would also lead to great economic collapse because no-one would trust stocks anymore.
Insider trading laws do not violate the first amendment because they do not restrict speech, but actions (i.e., trading).
I fail to see what's amoral about trading based on information that other people don't know. There are no two people who know the exact same things. All trade is based on asymmetric information.
Seeing as how you are moving the goalposts now you probably see very clearly what is amoral about insider trading.
How is that comparable to insider trading? There is no fraud involved with insider trading.
If the engine is about to burst, caveat emptor.
It is likely that the repeal of insider trading laws would prompt a greater investment in discovering insider information and making that information known to the market faster. Firms that do nothing but specialize in getting insider information would crop up. Those in the know would eventually have to assume that their counter-parties may have the same information perhaps through the same information contact or through different ones that have the same info.
If you really play through the scenario of removing the restriction posed by insider trading laws, you'll see that things aren't really better or worse in terms of the greater good. Without insider trading laws, there is no victim since the victim knows they are playing a different game. The laws themselves are responsible for permitting victimization to occur in the first place since it implies the expectation of trust where there often isn't any.
Could you explain this claim?
If insider trading is illegal you will want to announce this news as quickly as you can so that your company is viewed as being transparent and shareholder friendly.
This sort of info is already kept secret for as long as possible, for both contractual and commercial reasons. At least if the officers are trading on it the info is leaking out in some way. So, for this specific example, allowing insider trading will decrease volatility. (I'm not convinced that's so valuable, but it's the sort of thing many people care about.)
I can't think of any company that acts as if they care to be "viewed as being transparent and shareholder friendly", so apparently that isn't so important.
It's just ridiculous that Congress conducts insider trading while other people are persecuted for it.
Insider trading laws are a violation of the first amendment, as restricting what I can communicate to someone else is censorship and abridgement of free speech.