Re:Good Old Excel is the Ultimate Data Visualization Tool
by pfortuny on Wednesday October 16, 2013 @12:28PM
(#6560544)
Despite not liking the NYT example (too much clutter to my sight and using faces conveys little information because they are difficult to match and to distinguish), I really look forward to an age in which data analysts treat readers as intelligent and show data as data, not as nice plots.
The problem with charts is twofold:
a) They are very very easily turned into ideological tools.
b) They are very very easily turned into 'kitsch' pastiches made by uninformed people trying to make beautiful-looking summaries.
Look at the charts here (population density http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Population_density): is it good or bad to have a population density of >500? Is it even good or bad to have it at 41-500? What would you have thought if the colors were reversed? Compare with this one (deforestation http://www.cryonie.com/en/world/images/map-deforestation.jpg): is it good or bad to have forests?
Re:Good Old Excel is the Ultimate Data Visualization Tool
by cyrillevincey on Wednesday October 16, 2013 @08:11AM
(#6559125)
"the beauty of the table as a visualization": you are right, I shall try a blog about that. Thanks for your priceless urls.
I was hoping the OP would focus on the beauty of the table as a visualization, something I wish was used more often despite its simplicity.
Tufte's small multiples is a kind of table, and a very effective one. This was one of my favorite examples he uses in his books, and helped to get Gotti acquitted:
http://www.thejuryexpert.com/wp-content/uploads/gotti.jpg
Here's a modern take by the NYTimes:
http://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2012/08/24/sports/top-fin...