we are thinking about ways we can connect the two together in a tighter way to reduce some of this
as you point out, twitter and disqus are USV portfolio companies and we love using and supporting the products our portfolio companies make
On that... nail on the head.
It would be good if you could add a subtle addition of highlighting the things on the board in that a USV team member has contributed.
I think of VC firms as akin to a curator of interesting companies and opportunities, and that the sum of the portfolio reflects strongly the personal curation of the VCs. It'd be ace to see that shine through this new board.
The only conflict in that is whether you see this board as becoming more than USV, or giving an insight into USV. If the former than you'd be right to hesitate about highlighting the team's contributions, if the latter then do it already.
At least 25% of the time that I've clicked on a comments link, I've had to sit around (after the page has loaded!) waiting for Disqus to load the comments (what I actually came to see). Sometimes they don't even load at all and I have to refresh the page. I completely understand that you guys love supporting your portfolio companies, but it seems like this type of site isn't quite as well suited for Disqus.
Just my two cents. I'm excited to see how you guys improve on this, and other than these issues I think you've done a great job so far.
I think you could benefit more from automatically analyzing links from many sources than to implement a sharing service yourself.
but only time will tell if we are right about that
we once tried to play in a corner of that space as well (focused more on expertise/ context), but it is clearly a chicken & egg situation.
Twitter login and author info, standalone posts (submitted links/stories), and Disqus comments.
It feels broken already, using a strange mix of identity from one communication tool and the interface from another ✝.
What I like is that by connecting to Twitter and using the USV team's accounts as the source you get a great idea of the character and interests of the VC team and fund.
What I dislike is that by opening that up to anyone, the front-page just becomes a mini-HN and the insight into the character of the team is immediately diluted.
I also dislike that they use Twitter identity as the author for a conversation/debate, but then use Disqus as the medium for the debate. This has two effects:
1) It breaks the feel of the audience, people present themselves slightly differently to different groups, for example how many HN profile pages carry identical info on the individual's Twitter page?
2) It splits the debate across Twitter (where some will reply directly to the author) and Disqus.
I also find the blog post placement weird. All of the design hints on the blog posts (the grey squares to the right) make me think that they are stories, just "Hot" stories that are being featured. Not the case though, grey squares are blog posts that are masquerading as submitted stories (the design consistency of the block).
It's a weird experience overall. I liked the effect that was achieved early-on of gaining insight into what the team are following and debating, but it feels confusing. Ultimately I think the best thing to do is just to follow interesting people on Twitter to gain this insight, follow trends and interests.
✝ Should probably be pointed out that Twitter and Disqus are both portfolio companies of USV, and perhaps that's why they chose to do this weird mashup. Makes me wonder about the comedy gold or real opportunities that might be achieved from mashups of other portfolio company offerings. Code academy lessons that start where you left off, every time you get a cab using Hailo?