http://arewefastyet.com/#machine=11&view=breakdown&suite=asm...
There is no difference in approach between Firefox and Chrome there, both believe JITs can achieve excellent performance, and are always pushing that further. So both browsers "ignore" the "use asm" hint in that sense. The only difference is that Firefox, in addition, has an asm.js AOT module that detects asm.js and can optimize it very well (using the same backend as the JIT, but taking advantage of type information from the asm.js type system). But that AOT does not mean anything about the rest of the JS engine.
There are also a few runtime changes as well with asm.js code. For example, the JS engine knows that asm.js code cannot throw exceptions (asm.js code is very low-level, so JS exceptions are not possible), so it can avoid emitting some things it would normally emit in order to handle deopts due to exceptions and so forth. (Of course this does not require an AOT, a JIT could also detect the lack of need for that overhead, perhaps this is already done in some cases, but the AOT guarantees it is done for all asm.js code.)
Of course, the real solution is to fix the garbage collector, or (maybe) better yet, give user code a way to switch GC algorithms based on app-specific needs. Until then, the ability to manually manage memory is nothing to sneeze at.
>Q. Why not just keep optimizing JavaScript JIT compilers instead?
>A. No need to stop! But JIT compilers have less predictable performance based on complicated heuristics. The asm.js model provides a model closer to C/C++ by eliminating dynamic type guards, boxed values, and garbage collection.
It's an interesting approach but feels a bit like over-specialization. The V8 guys on the other hand, decided to ignore the directive entirely and have been able to improve their (more "generic") JIT compiler to get it to run the same code almost as fast as Firefox's Ahead-Of-Time compiler in a lot of cases.