Do you think this is related to impostor syndrome[1], or something different? Perhaps not as "harsh" as impostor syndrome?
This is why I'm not so sold on advice given by 'one-hit wonders,' people who scored big with a startup and are now seen as gurus because of it. I'm interested to hear what they say, but I'm skeptical.
I suspect what Amir is saying is that some successful people attribute their success to one thing, but that may not be the actual reason.
As an example - where the successful person has been clever enough to recognise their initial hypothesis for their success may have had flaws - many early Paul Graham essays credited the success of his Viaweb startup to the use of Lisp[1], while now most of his advice doesn't touch on a specific technology stack at all[2].
From my experience the things successful people credit for their success are infrequently wrong, but very often incomplete.
[1] eg, http://www.paulgraham.com/avg.html (from 2001)
[2] eg http://www.paulgraham.com/ds.html (2013)
For me, the items fall into 4 categories:
1. Go without saying, but need to be said anyway:
2. Interesting observation: 3. Sound important, but really aren't: 4. Insightful: Great list! Thanks for sharing, Amir.