Re:Matz: Ruby's Lisp features (2006)
by sjtgraham on Monday October 14, 2013 @09:50PM
(#6550971)
Removing homoiconicity means you no longer have a lisp.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
I disagree, by that definition Racket is not a lisp. AST macros are enough imo.
Racket isn't a Lisp. All of the Lisps have "Lisp" in their name, e.g MacLisp, Common Lisp, ZetaLisp, Interlisp, EuLisp, Elisp, etc.
Look at the conversation between kragen and lispm here [1].
Of course you can almost always informally call various Scheme dialects and Clojure "Lisps" (I do it all the time) because they draw very heavily from Lisps.
I said lisp not Lisp. I think it's meaningful to refer to things like Scheme, Racket, Arc, Clojure, Dylan, Honu et al as lowercase lisps.
For example I believe those tick off all 9 items on pg's list: http://www.paulgraham.com/diff.html
Disclaimer for language lawyers: Using lowercase lisp is not intended to infringe Lisp (R), a registered trademark of Sole Arbiter of What's a Lisp Corporation. ;)
Could you explain why Racket isn't homoiconic ?
It doesn't use S-Expressions internally, it uses a different representation called syntax objects. http://docs.racket-lang.org/guide/stx-obj.html