Re:How the .0001% Made Its Money
by TheZenPsycho on Monday October 14, 2013 @04:37PM
(#6549488)
There are four grid squares here, and you're ignoring two, and insisting that they are not important to consider.
here are the variables: father is a congressman (yes/no) took good advantage of opportunities (yes/no)
to combine them we have: yes/yes, yes/no, no/yes, no/no.
so you are saying that it didn't matter that his father was a congressman because he took advantage of his opportunities. But imagine a warren buffet who didn't have a well positioned family, and didn't have the opportunities he had- Still a wiley person- our no/yes. Where is he on the forbes 400?
Warren Buffet is not exactly a rags to riches story. It's more of a riches to unimaginable riches story.
Re:How the .0001% Made Its Money
by nonchalance on Monday October 14, 2013 @04:22PM
(#6549402)
Buffett is a perfect example of the problem: to be in the position to have those opportunities, you need a base and you need seed money. Having a family and friends round means you don't have the same type of pressure (they are generally far more willing to tolerate risk, give more room for experimentation, and are willing to write off lots of losses)
How is it "robbing" Buffett of his success to accurately describe the conditions of his success? When he writes about his own biography, it's along similar lines; he doesn't try to portray himself as a poor kid who pulled himself up by his bootstraps with nobody's help.
I wouldn't dream of robbing Buffet of his success - I'm describing the lengthy period of his life that occurred prior to his irrational obsession of buying a small textile company by the name of Berkshire. :)
The only thing that ultimately matters in investing is results. Buffett is the absolute worst example you could use to claim privilege results. Unless your theory is that his father's friends made all those investment decisions for him.
Just about the hardest thing to do in business would be to generate a $300 billion company on the back of one man's dozens of investment decisions. Trying to rob Buffett of that stunning success because his grandfather owned some tiny stores in Omaha, is beyond ridiculous.