News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Overdosing on Celebrity Gossip, The News, and Low Quality... by mattgreenrocks on Monday October 14, 2013 @03:07PM (#6548997)
Everywhere you find addicted users, look at who is feeding them, and you'll find perverse incentives: whether they're page views, contextual ads, or in-app purchases. Aggregators compete amongst one another for users, so they trickle out all content. They claim that quality content is voted to the top, but it is ultimately thinly-masked groupthink. Comment sections are often intellectual wastelands rife with people needing to yell and/or 'win' Internet points for no reason at all.

The world needs innovative thought, not people reinforcing the 'right' opinions. I find social media is particularly bad at this: why is it normal to ingest everyone's opinions on a daily basis? Why don't we want that mental space for ourselves?

We're far too content with the cheap substitutes for things that truly satisfy us. Facebook uses this to great effect, and aggregators do too.

Re:Overdosing on Celebrity Gossip, The News, and Low Quality... by humanrebar on Monday October 14, 2013 @03:55PM (#6549256)
There is plenty of innovative thought out there. The problem is the lack of efficiency in requiring that every individual find and consume the best innovative thought on her own.

Also, I agree that modern manners insist on a a very peurile fear of conflict, which leads to strong segregation of viewpoints, groupthink, a lack of empathy, and even an ignorance of alternate viewpoints.

What we need, among other things, is a new set of manners that encourage conflicting opinions (or even debate) while providing ground rules for avoiding harm to feelings, reputations, and relationships. The fact is, if people become hurt, angry, or withdrawn when someone simply disagrees (let alone argues) with their viewpoint, there is not really any hope for breaking everyone out of their echo chambers. It's simply not worth it to antagonize people for the sake of calling Scientology bogus or homeopathy a waste of money.

And as long as that is the case, I don't see news aggregators (including all forms of journalism) promoting against-the-grain or otherwise uncomfortable information within their respective echo chambers.

Re:Overdosing on Celebrity Gossip, The News, and Low Quality... by mattgreenrocks on Tuesday October 15, 2013 @10:17AM (#6553311)
And this is the true sadness: new media suffers from the exact same biases/critical flaws of old media. Except it's OK this time, because it's a different set of biases.