Re:Polyphasic Sleep: One Man's 6-Month Experiment (2005)
by encoderer on Saturday June 13, 2009 @06:01PM
(#656548)
As an observer, I appreciate the debate, and I'll add that it doesn't seem to me like you're talking past each other. Giving the other gentlemen the benefit of the doubt that he's something of an expert on this subject, it seems he's very clearly understanding your point and offering his opinion to the contrary.
I, myself, have nothing much to add in the way of hard facts, but using logic, I think that sleep-as-an-energy-saver seems off. Sleep seems like a highly vulnerable state for early animals. If the only initial benefit of sleep was energy conservation, it seems like animals that simply chose to rest would have an edge upon those that slept. By resting, they'd conserve the same energy, but would stay alert and responsive.
And it interests me that animals that cannot rest (sharks, for example) still sleep.
PS: Your liver does many things necessary for you to live. It also does many things that help you live a better life. Talking about what your liver or sleep does, without including the useful side effects is not the full story. Sleep deprivation hinders memory formation in humans and hinders reaction times. Are those related to the core function of sleep or just a codependence developed due to other useful features of sleep? I don’t think there is a clear separation between the two.
Edit: I can't read that link.