Re:DRM/EME in HTML5 - an American thing
by shmerl on Sunday October 13, 2013 @02:05PM
(#6543483)
> DRM is already a required and de facto standard for the Open Web
How is it required? Browser makers have to implement it to adhere to standards? Site makers have to use it to adhere to standards? No, nothing like that. DRM is an optional junk now. Making it a standard promotes it to mandatory status.
Also, the statement that DRM is a "standard for the open Web" is an oxymoron. It's like saying that spreading disease (not vaccines) is a standard for curing. DRM is a complete antithesis of openness.
So, to correct what you said, it should read: DRM is already a required and de facto standard for the closed Web. And those who really care about the open Web should oppose DRM everywhere. DRM should be marginalized, through plugins and 3rd party non trusted black boxes which are hard to use and which are very apparently a problem. Not integrated with comfort through EME and the like, which only masks the problem, but doesn't solve it. To give a clear analogy - hidden surveillance camera is not better because it's hidden, it's actually worse because people don't think about it. "Unobtrusive", "comfortable" and etc. DRM is not better - it's always much worse.
How is it required? Browser makers have to implement it to adhere to standards? Site makers have to use it to adhere to standards? No, nothing like that. DRM is an optional junk now. Making it a standard promotes it to mandatory status.
Also, the statement that DRM is a "standard for the open Web" is an oxymoron. It's like saying that spreading disease (not vaccines) is a standard for curing. DRM is a complete antithesis of openness.
So, to correct what you said, it should read: DRM is already a required and de facto standard for the closed Web. And those who really care about the open Web should oppose DRM everywhere. DRM should be marginalized, through plugins and 3rd party non trusted black boxes which are hard to use and which are very apparently a problem. Not integrated with comfort through EME and the like, which only masks the problem, but doesn't solve it. To give a clear analogy - hidden surveillance camera is not better because it's hidden, it's actually worse because people don't think about it. "Unobtrusive", "comfortable" and etc. DRM is not better - it's always much worse.