> That would be far less of a setback for the open web
> than the current state, which bakes the notion of
> restricted access into the open standards.
If widespread restrictions are going to exist anyway, then it's strictly better for the interface to be standardized.The status quo is that Linux users are already locked out of Netflix.
The only reason that Cyanogenmod users aren't is because they can run the standard Android apk, which, incidentally, is a separate proprietary blob that Netflix had to write and produce on their own dime.
I'd rather vendors be forced to ship proprietary binaries that they have to produce themselves than for them to offload the work onto open-source browsers (or, worse, be able to pressure open-source browsers to cripple their own functionality in order to preserve DRM).
> If widespread restrictions are going to exist anyway, then it's strictly better for the interface to be standardized.
If widespread restrictions are going to exist, it's better for them to be less convenient for everyone involved (both consumers and distributors), not more.
Those widespread restrictions imply that only proprietary browsers and operating systems can use EME.
However "standardizing" the interface gives those proprietary companies the opportunity to claim that their solution is "standards compliant", while in reality the standard is a farce and their solutions are nothing of the kind.
No, that's not the expectation of EME opponents. EME opponents understand that companies will continue to use restricted access, as they always have, but want them to do it off-spec and on their own dime.
> If EME is blocked, then these companies will either start distributing their own customized locked-down applications ("You must install the Netflix Player to watch this movie"), or will work privately with the major proprietary browser platforms (IE, Safari, Android Chrome, ChromeOS) to implement what they demand. Firefox and Chrom{e,ium} will be left out in the cold, and the advancement of the open web will se a significant setback.
That would be far less of a setback for the open web than the current state, which bakes the notion of restricted access into the open standards.