> Statistically, more men have won Nobel prizes than women (by a large margin). Most Nobel laureates are Caucasian. Most are from the western hemisphere. Other than gender, it may be interpreted to mean that if a group which makes a small fraction of the total world population, they must be better/smarter.
Consider your magnitudes though.
For example, men win
0.961/0.5 = 1.9
times the Nobel Prizes you would expect based on representation alone, whereas Jews win
0.202/0.002 = 101
times the Nobel Prizes you would expect based on representation alone.
Re:Jewish Nobel Laureates
by tedunangst on Saturday October 12, 2013 @01:36AM
(#6537432)
Wouldn't percentage of Jews in the Western world be a better stat, given that's more or less the population from which Nobel prize winners are selected?
Re:Jewish Nobel Laureates
by downandout on Saturday October 12, 2013 @12:15AM
(#6537244)
Agreed. I'm not sure why this belongs on HN. It seems very divisive and out of place in the context of the HN community. This list is very short in comparison: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_black_Nobel_Laureates . Should we be promoting all of the negative connotations associated with that when compared to the Jewish list?
Thanks. I had submitted that link to the "Black Nobel Laureates" earlier and let it sit for 30 minutes after no upvotes, then deleted it. Made it appear as if this thread was pride-based upvoting that de-evolved into "Jews have super human intelligence" with no discussion on socioeconomics.
What have you said in this thread about socioeconomics?
The nature of variance means that you would expect to find the highest and lowest means in groups with the smallest populations.
I can understand saying a statistic might be partly confounded by additional factors. I can't understand calling it meaningless. Just that it might not mean exactly what's implied. The stat itself is pretty hard to miss.
As another commenter noted, the smaller the group, the higher the variance. Extreme cases due to variance actually are quite meaningless.
I am not claiming that this particular statistic is meaningless. Just that it isn't necessarily meaningful, either.
Statistically, more men have won Nobel prizes than women (by a large margin). Most Nobel laureates are Caucasian. Most are from the western hemisphere. Other than gender, it may be interpreted to mean that if a group which makes a small fraction of the total world population, they must be better/smarter.
It's a fallacious argument of course, since there can be many other factors at play here. How much of it is because these groups have access to more funds, that most of them are based in the United States which has better and more well-funded universities? What about social factors that have nothing to do with race/religion?
Along these lines, I could submit a link about how Indians who make up a tiny fraction of the American population are so much more successful than $POPULATION [1], but it's a meaningless statistic to have, other than for some misplaced pride.
1. http://www.forbes.com/2009/02/24/bobby-jindal-indian-america...