News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:My YC idea: User-created-language by veritas on Tuesday October 09, 2007 @02:00PM (#65366)
I agree there are slight advantages to images, but there is still something lost in translation.

How would explain a concept such as searching? Or a hyperlink?

Granted those are some contrived examples, but whatever problems we have with text and losses in translation, we'll also have (perhaps to a lesser extent, perhaps to a greater extent) in picture messaging.

These are just my 2 cents.

5000 years from now, I hope we would have advanced enough to instantly translate (correctly) from one language to another. Or just speak one language.

Re:My YC idea: User-created-language by carter on Tuesday October 09, 2007 @04:02PM (#65430)
I agree. There are must be some losses in translation, cos pictures are just approximations to the elements of thinking process. Pictures have some "cross-platform" features, but their expression power much lower than language's. Ex. consider that language 1 has expresson power x, pictures have expression power y (x > y). And language 2 has expression power z (x = z). Then we're trying to reduce x to y and then take it to z again.

Instead of this we must take x to w (w > x) and then reduce w to z. A human translator going exactly this way.

Re:My YC idea: User-created-language by cellis on Tuesday October 09, 2007 @02:08PM (#65370)
hah! no need with my neuro-transmitter 3000!