Re:Why being a macroeconomist means never having to say you'...
by randallsquared on Thursday June 11, 2009 @05:16PM
(#653646)
You can get some important and interesting insights from economic statistical data, but macroeconomics is a series of just-so stories, at best; it isn't even really the same thing as microeconomics. Microeconomics deals, in part at least, with things you can run experiments on, with actual controls. Macro, not so much; like politics, you can find a macro pundit to give pretty much any conclusion you'd like, even when they mostly agree on micro.
[Edit: apparently I'm just rephrasing the article summary. I guess I should have read it before ranting...]
And for what it's worth, industrial output has fallen at a pace faster than during the beginning of the Great Depression. That we haven't seen similar knockon effects (30% unemployment?) is most likely due to government stimulus ala Keynes. Now it is fair to claim that the economy has more services and less goods, so the GD isn't a perfect comparison, but it is pretty good.
See, eg, (industrial output) http://voxeu.org/files/image/eichengreen_update_fig1.gif
(world trade -- more important now than then) http://voxeu.org/files/image/eichengreen_update_fig3.gif
(industrial output, 4 big europeans) http://voxeu.org/files/image/biigeuro.gif
Source: http://voxeu.org/index.php?q=node/3421