Re:Cryptographic Right Answers
by tptacek on Thursday June 11, 2009 @04:08PM
(#653513)
I'm actually not anti-CTR mode; my recommendation (use EAX mode) has basically the same problem --- EAX is just CTR + OMAC.
You're right that stream ciphers blow up more spectacularly than block encryption does. You have to be sure not to re-use anything (counters, nonces, keys, etc). If "don't overfill a buffer" is an easy prescription that cost industry $4+bn USD, it's hard to imagine how unlikely it is people can avoid screwing up "don't reuse anything".
On the other hand, differentiatable errors cause spectacular problems with block encryption. See: the "bad padding" error message that decrypts entire AES blocks a byte at a time.
You're right that stream ciphers blow up more spectacularly than block encryption does. You have to be sure not to re-use anything (counters, nonces, keys, etc). If "don't overfill a buffer" is an easy prescription that cost industry $4+bn USD, it's hard to imagine how unlikely it is people can avoid screwing up "don't reuse anything".
On the other hand, differentiatable errors cause spectacular problems with block encryption. See: the "bad padding" error message that decrypts entire AES blocks a byte at a time.