News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How Harvey Mudd Transformed Its CS Program And Nearly Clo... by codexon on Friday October 11, 2013 @01:59AM (#6531621)
Citation needed.

It is much more plausible that these engineering colleges have laxer requirements for females in order to get a 50/50 gender balance rather than public school discrimination.

Re:How Harvey Mudd Transformed Its CS Program And Nearly Clo... by arthulia on Friday October 11, 2013 @02:08AM (#6531641)
Citation needed.

Anecdotal rebuttal: I know a bunch of female students at Harvey Mudd and that doesn't appear to be the case.

Re:How Harvey Mudd Transformed Its CS Program And Nearly Clo... by codexon on Friday October 11, 2013 @02:29AM (#6531700)
It doesn't need a citation, it is supported by Occam's razor while you are suggesting a complex explanation.

How does Harvey Mudd magically close their gender gap as though they suddenly decided to stop discriminating against females all these years?

If the girls you knew were, say 10% less capable compared to male applicants, would you be able to tell? I doubt it.

Re:How Harvey Mudd Transformed Its CS Program And Nearly Clo... by arthulia on Friday October 11, 2013 @02:46AM (#6531752)
> If the girls you knew were, say 10% less capable compared to male applicants, would you be able to tell? I doubt it.

If you can't tell then what difference does it make?

Re:How Harvey Mudd Transformed Its CS Program And Nearly Clo... by codexon on Friday October 11, 2013 @03:01AM (#6531796)
It makes a difference to the male applicants that would've been accepted if there wasn't a bias.
Re:How Harvey Mudd Transformed Its CS Program And Nearly Clo... by davorak on Friday October 11, 2013 @07:05AM (#6532378)
A program erasing the current cultural bias/momentum against females will make a difference to all the females who will not have to face said momentum/bias.
Re:How Harvey Mudd Transformed Its CS Program And Nearly Clo... by codexon on Friday October 11, 2013 @03:59PM (#6535583)
But how do you know that a 50/50 balance is even natural in engineering fields like CS?

Why isn't there a 50/50 balance and other similar initiatives for males for female dominated subjects like nursing and education?

Re:How Harvey Mudd Transformed Its CS Program And Nearly Clo... by davorak on Friday October 11, 2013 @05:28PM (#6536040)
Is there solid evidence of an IQ difference between the genders or a general subject, with a biological understanding of why such a difference exists?

I currently have not come across any such solid evidence and biological understanding. Seems unproductive to operate under an understanding far from 50/50 when I do not have solid evidence that I should be.

Re:How Harvey Mudd Transformed Its CS Program And Nearly Clo... by codexon on Friday October 11, 2013 @05:37PM (#6536070)
I never brought up the argument that males are smarter than females.

Why wouldn't you consider the possibility that most females don't want to sit in front of a screen all day with minimal social interaction often working 70 hour weeks?

Is it because you feel that the field of CS is so superior that no one could dislike it?

Re:How Harvey Mudd Transformed Its CS Program And Nearly Clo... by davorak on Friday October 11, 2013 @06:08PM (#6536186)
> I never brought up the argument that males are smarter than females.

I was not implying you did. IQ is one well know metric but others such as "a general subject", as I asked for before, are welcome as well.

I asked for solid evidence that operating away form 50/50 is more productive. If you have some I am willing to look it over.

Re:How Harvey Mudd Transformed Its CS Program And Nearly Clo... by codexon on Friday October 11, 2013 @06:18PM (#6536221)
I don't know why you assume that 50/50 is the desired ratio when acceptance is supposed to be self-selected and merit based.

This CS professor from MIT explains why fewer females choose engineering studies like CS.

http://philip.greenspun.com/careers/women-in-science

Specifically this quote.

> What about women? Don't they want to impress their peers? Yes, but they are more discriminating about choosing those peers. I've taught a fair number of women students in electrical engineering and computer science classes over the years. I can give you a list of the ones who had the best heads on their shoulders and were the most thoughtful about planning out the rest of their lives. Their names are on files in my "medical school recommendations" directory.

Re:How Harvey Mudd Transformed Its CS Program And Nearly Clo... by davorak on Friday October 11, 2013 @06:47PM (#6536319)
> I don't know why you assume that 50/50 is the desired ratio when acceptance is supposed to be self-selected and merit based.

I was not trying to communicate my desire. Rather what is optimal? I need strong evidence to operate far from 50/50.

> Specifically this quote.

This counts as evidence, but not enough evidence to get me to think the optimum is close to having 14-18% female CS degree recipients(2010).

Nice graph over time: http://blogs.computerworld.com/sites/computerworld.com/files... from article: http://blogs.computerworld.com/it-careers/21993/women-comput...

Summary statistics: http://www.ncwit.org/sites/default/files/legacy/pdf/BytheNum...

Re:How Harvey Mudd Transformed Its CS Program And Nearly Clo... by codexon on Friday October 11, 2013 @09:31PM (#6536877)
You prefer 50/50 but you have no evidence to even suggest that this is the "best" distribution for CS let alone any other major.

Why can't you accept the possibility that females do not like CS as much as males do not like things like nursing or human resources?

If there is a social stigma, should we really force people who normally wouldn't choose it so we can have a 50/50 ratio just because that is the probability to be born as?

Who are you to say that they are happier doing CS instead of what they would've chosen without all this influence?

Re:How Harvey Mudd Transformed Its CS Program And Nearly Clo... by davorak on Friday October 11, 2013 @10:21PM (#6536988)
> You prefer 50/50 but you have no evidence to even suggest that this is the "best" distribution for CS let alone any other major.

50/50 is the default with out additional information. Again I am not trying to statement my preferences.

> Why can't you accept the possibility that females do not like CS as much as males do not like things like nursing or human resources?

I did not say I can not. Like any idea I want good evidence and solid understanding to make strong claims.

> If there is a social stigma, should we really force people who normally wouldn't choose it so we can have a 50/50 ratio just because that is the probability to be born as?

I have not seen anyone make the argument to force people to take CS courses.

> Who are you to say that they are happier doing CS instead of what they would've chosen without all this influence?

Trying is better then not trying. Influence exist weather intentional or not. Unintentional influences are not inherently better then intentional.

Re:How Harvey Mudd Transformed Its CS Program And Nearly Clo... by arthulia on Friday October 11, 2013 @03:17AM (#6531839)
With only 660 students and around 3,000 highly qualified applicants, I'm pretty sure Mudd can be very picky about who they admit without introducing a bias.
Re:How Harvey Mudd Transformed Its CS Program And Nearly Clo... by davorak on Friday October 11, 2013 @06:59AM (#6532357)
The 48 percent statistic is for the junior year, the third year. It seems like your argument would require Mudd to grade females more lightly for the at least the first three years. This seems unlikely since it would require some form of collusion between all/most CS professors(maybe TAs too).
Re:How Harvey Mudd Transformed Its CS Program And Nearly Clo... by codexon on Friday October 11, 2013 @04:26PM (#6535754)
I don't follow this argument. You are suggesting that the rate of females leaving the major/school is exactly proportional to the grade they get.

I don't believe anyone would quit a school/major because they scored a little bit lower average. This might be possible if they all happened to be near the threshold for failing but I doubt Mudd is this strict.

Also everyone is well aware of affirmative action, so even if their grades were worse they would not think they would not be able to compete for the same jobs/academic positions.

Re:How Harvey Mudd Transformed Its CS Program And Nearly Clo... by davorak on Friday October 11, 2013 @05:24PM (#6536019)
> I don't follow this argument. You are suggesting that the rate of females leaving the major/school is exactly proportional to the grade they get.

The percentage of females normal drops year by year in the CS programs I am familiar with. This does not seem to be happening at Mudd to the degree it does elsewhere. I have not see you put forward how initial acceptance has changed this trend, or that the trend exists at Mudd and they simply start the first year with a high female ratio say 40%-60% male-female.

> I don't believe anyone would quit a school/major because they scored a little bit lower average. This might be possible if they all happened to be near the threshold for failing but I doubt Mudd is this strict.

People do switch majors when they are below average, not always but I would be surprised if this reason is rare. Your argument now requires that the females are below average compared to the males but not so below average that they want to switch majors. I would count this as a minor complexity penalty to your argument.

> Also everyone is well aware of affirmative action, so even if their grades were worse they would not think they would not be able to compete for the same jobs/academic positions.

This by it self does not work at most universities. So what makes Mudd different that this argument works there?

Re:How Harvey Mudd Transformed Its CS Program And Nearly Clo... by codexon on Friday October 11, 2013 @06:05PM (#6536177)
> The percentage of females normal drops year by year in the CS programs I am familiar with. This does not seem to be happening at Mudd to the degree it does elsewhere. I have not see you put forward how initial acceptance has changed this trend, or that the trend exists at Mudd and they simply start the first year with a high female ratio say 40%-60% male-female.

Extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence. The burden of proof lies with you, not with me.

> People do switch majors when they are below average, not always but I would be surprised if this reason is rare. Your argument now requires that the females are below average compared to the males but not so below average that they want to switch majors. I would count this as a minor complexity penalty to your argument.

This is not complex at all. Switching majors is major decision with many roadblocks. You will need approval and you will likely need to retake courses. This has dire implications such as wasting credits which means you will need more money to stay in college longer. You might even lose scholarships.

All evidence points that differences between ranked individuals will be difficult to see. In activities that are completely quantifiable such as Olympic racing, the difference between the top people are measured in milliseconds, so it is quite feasible that the difference between male and female CS students at a selective college is similarly small in terms of absolute measurements.

> This by it self does not work at most universities. So what makes Mudd different that this argument works there?

What makes Mudd different is that they accepted more females to start with. This reasoning causes minorities to stay, it doesn't increase the number of acceptances.

Re:How Harvey Mudd Transformed Its CS Program And Nearly Clo... by davorak on Friday October 11, 2013 @07:07PM (#6536398)
> Extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence. The burden of proof lies with you, not with me.

You will have to explain what claim you find extraordinary and what specific evidence you would find convincing for me to consider doing research to provide some.

> This is not complex at all.

I did not call it complex. You made an argument by occam's razor if details are added to the argument to make it viable it make it more complex and it benefits less from occam's razor. My argument or your added details:

> All evidence points that differences between ranked individuals will be difficult to see. In activities that are completely quantifiable such as Olympic racing, the difference between the top people are measured in milliseconds, so it is quite feasible that the difference between male and female CS students at a selective college is similarly small in terms of absolute measurements.

Weaken an occam's razor argument, some times called applying a complexity penalty.

> What makes Mudd different is that they accepted more females to start with. This reasoning causes minorities to stay, it doesn't increase the number of acceptances.

If I understand you correctly you think that the percentage of females in the 1st through graduation is controlled tightly by the starting percentage. Do you just expect it to hold steady for all 4 years?

Re:How Harvey Mudd Transformed Its CS Program And Nearly Clo... by codexon on Friday October 11, 2013 @08:58PM (#6536785)
I already repeated multiple times what claim I find ordinary: that Mudd is somehow able to retain so many female CS majors simply by accepting more.

It is up to you to prove that they are able to do this otherwise.

> You made an argument by occam's razor if details are added to the argument to make it viable it make it more complex and it benefits less from occam's razor. My argument or your added details

I only explained the common sense reasoning that you somehow keep ignoring. I did not add any details the argument, merely to reinforce the fact that my argument stems from common sense while yours appears to make wild conjectures on how Harvey Mudd is better than every other CS department.

Re:How Harvey Mudd Transformed Its CS Program And Nearly Clo... by davorak on Friday October 11, 2013 @10:51PM (#6537049)
> I already repeated multiple times what claim I find ordinary: that Mudd is somehow able to retain so many female CS majors simply by accepting more. It is up to you to prove that they are able to do this otherwise.

State your prediction for the female population by year dependent on initial enrollment percentage and I will consider do some hard research and bring it back.

> I did not add any details the argument, merely to reinforce the fact that my argument stems from common sense

Occam's razor argument is usually only effective if their is a obvious difference in the complexity of the two arguments. The details are often needed to establish weather or not their is a significant complexity difference.

> yours appears to make wild conjectures on how Harvey Mudd is better than every other CS department.

Is their a particular claim you are referencing? I try to stay away from making wild conjectures.

Re:How Harvey Mudd Transformed Its CS Program And Nearly Clo... by coryrc on Friday October 11, 2013 @02:34AM (#6531721)
Please use "women" instead of "girls", unless you are talking about children under ~11.
Re:How Harvey Mudd Transformed Its CS Program And Nearly Clo... by dnautics on Friday October 11, 2013 @02:38AM (#6531729)
what if they're under 21? I'd call a male college student a boy in most situations.
Re:How Harvey Mudd Transformed Its CS Program And Nearly Clo... by arthulia on Friday October 11, 2013 @03:07AM (#6531810)
Point taken although I'm not sure I agree. I hope "female students" is an acceptable compromise.
Re:How Harvey Mudd Transformed Its CS Program And Nearly Clo... by Tichy on Friday October 11, 2013 @03:26AM (#6531861)
How would the students know that they had laxer requirements?