News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Wikileaks internal memo on "The Fifth Estate" by rurounijones on Friday October 11, 2013 @01:28AM (#6531538)
Couldn't they sue the film-makers for defamation / libel / slander (whichever one it is) for the "2,000 informants harmed" claim?

Be hard for the "Based on a true story" defense to work for that I would think.

Re:Wikileaks internal memo on "The Fifth Estate" by sidi on Friday October 11, 2013 @01:36AM (#6531559)
Although it contains real names and real places, the film will justify itself as fictional making it harder to target for defamation / libel / slander.

Edit: Another way the film can get off the hook is by claiming the information depicted is based on the sources (books) it uses for forming the script. I can only speculate, but what matters is shaping the public opinion and they are doing it by leaking the script and expressing their opposition to it.

Another guess is they need definitive evidence before sueing the film/makers. To quote from their memo: "Although the film has premiered at the Toronto International Film Festival and numerous other media organizations have been shown review copies, the studio continues to refuse to show the film to WikiLeaks staff."

Re:Wikileaks internal memo on "The Fifth Estate" by rurounijones on Friday October 11, 2013 @01:38AM (#6531568)
That would seem like a very flimsy defence. If I were wikileaks I would be arguing that one.
Re:Wikileaks internal memo on "The Fifth Estate" by tehwalrus on Friday October 11, 2013 @11:47AM (#6533862)
certainly in the UK weasel words get you precisely nowhere in Libel. If you know what you were saying, and your audience knew it too, then you can be sued.
Re:Wikileaks internal memo on "The Fifth Estate" by ttctciyf on Friday October 11, 2013 @07:14AM (#6532395)
Yeah, this has puzzled me from the start with this film. Normally unapproved bio pics based on a living person at least change the name (viz: Citizen Hearst, ... um, sorry, Kane, right?) out of fear of libel action, I thought.

I can't think of any other film that blatantly sets out to tell a fictional story injurious to the reputation of a living person without renaming them. (Well, My Name Is Bruce, arguably, I guess. But that starred and was directed and co-produced by the "victim", something of an exception.)

I'd love to see Carter-Ruck take this on in a British libel case!

Re:Wikileaks internal memo on "The Fifth Estate" by commandar on Friday October 11, 2013 @09:08AM (#6532805)
> Normally unapproved bio pics based on a living person at least change the name

They do? Jobs? The Social Network?

Re:Wikileaks internal memo on "The Fifth Estate" by ttctciyf on Friday October 11, 2013 @11:47AM (#6533864)
Well, libellous ones, anyhow :)

You're right of course, though not sure that Jobs is quite "based on a living person" (though he was alive when the project started, just not when it was released.)

Re:Wikileaks internal memo on "The Fifth Estate" by andyjohnson0 on Friday October 11, 2013 @04:47AM (#6532036)
It would be difficult for Assange to appear in court to give evidence.
Re:Wikileaks internal memo on "The Fifth Estate" by Rebelgecko on Friday October 11, 2013 @06:51AM (#6532336)
Having seen the movie, I don't remember it actually making the claim that 2000 informants were harmed.