The problem is that in the absence of actual news gathering, editorializing becomes either navel-gazing or shilling for whatever bias you have. It's hard to have meaningful editorials about government spying on its citizens or companies shipping shoddy products if you don't actually have the news of such things in the first place due to a lack of revenue to fund investigative reporting.
There is of course the possibility of citizen journalism devoid of any substantial revenue model, but the passion necessary for Joe Smith to take time from his normal life to dig around dumpsters probably reveals an existing bias to begin with, so you're back to the editorial without dependable news on which to base it.
There's a reason it's a hard problem that few news organizations have come remotely close to solving.
I think that one issue here is that the news reader apps focus on user experience while most of the content providers focus on content (and frankly, provide a relatively awful user experience). I think that to have a successful news product, you have to provide both. If you look at the classic periodic news/opinion model, the magazine, you had a strong marriage of both aspects of the overall product. The confounding issue for content providers right now is that they all give the milk away for free, and so it's trivial for aggregaters to both focus on user experience AND have more quality content than any particular content provider. But if there was a shift in the content industry away from allowing aggregaters to use their content, then perhaps individual content providers could compete. However, I expect that to succeed in such an environment that the content providers would have to become desirable destinations in their own right.
Blogging :)
Also Upworthy was a very interesting example of a successful news startup: http://www.businessinsider.com/how-upworthy-grew-to-104-mill...
It does cost money to report on things, and people who spend their time thinking about the issues and summarizing them or coralling them together. And historically those people were paid by the fees from Classified Ads [1].
What was interesting in the 'old school' was that the classifieds of the newspaper that had the most readers did best, and so they could charge the most for them, and subscribers and circulation became the variable you maximized to make your paper successful. But in the 'new school' there is no single paper, there is the web, and it has voices from all over and all of the ad revenue is going to places like Craigslist and Google so the support cost of serious news is 'gone' or its entirely subscriber based.
TPM is 100% correct in that it gets no benefit from Flipboard (or Feedly, or whatever) in showing its story if it never sees the reader.
People are willing to pay for editorial, the New York times, the Economist, and others have shown that. But how do you create their scale or markets these days? Can you even make a 'lean startup' type organization based on editorial content? That will be an interesting question for the current generation of entrepreneurs, and a vital question to Journalism/English majors everywhere.
[1] http://www.mediabistro.com/mediajobsdaily/mediamemo-google-d...