Re:GoDaddy Pulls Lavabit's Security Creds Because the FBI Go...
by tsaoutourpants on Thursday October 10, 2013 @11:50AM
(#6528355)
I agree. But like virtually any site of which I am aware, Lavabit didn't force PFS. It's browser-negotiated. The "funny" thing is that there's a good chance that any one user might have been using PFS, so it's less likely that they can get a specific user's data (Snowden) and more likely that they can get a random sampling of other, non-target users' data.
If you use a protocol that supports perfect forward secrecy, and you ought to, then the private key is used only to authenticate the ephemeral session key, not to encrypt it. Compromise of the private key does not allow previous sessions to be decrypted. (Compromise does allow impersonation, though, which is why you need pre-distributed certificate revocations.)