News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Startups Cooperative: Workable or Pie in the Sky Fantasy? by edw519 on Tuesday October 09, 2007 @08:45AM (#65234)
I don't like the idea and here's why.

At the earliest stages, you don't know what will give you a competitive advantage. You may think you do, but you really don't. As things get off the ground, you may find yourself in a totally different business that what you planned.

I have had several experiences where I rolled out several tools needed to do the real work, and it turned out that the tools became the product. Who knew. Good thing I didn't share them or I would've ended up with nothing.

Finding a community of like minded people, either in person or a place like here is a great idea. Sharing what you've got before you know what's really important might not be.

Re:Startups Cooperative: Workable or Pie in the Sky Fantasy? by Kaizyn on Tuesday October 09, 2007 @11:12AM (#65274)
This is an excellent point. Had Joel Spolsky 'shared' the bug tracking system in such a cooperative pool, things would have turned out dramatically different for FogBugz.
Re:Startups Cooperative: Workable or Pie in the Sky Fantasy? by darose on Tuesday October 09, 2007 @01:42PM (#65357)
Absolutely true. He could have wound up being the creator of THE major bug tracking system, used by nearly all web developers, large and small, and have created a major company that makes loads of money off of providing services, enhancements, training, etc. to the massive ecosystem of users that he created.

Instead, he runs a small, fairly non-influential company that sells a pretty minor, non-differentiated, proprietary bug tracking system that nobody in the mainstream tech community uses.

Dunno - sharing worked pretty well for RedHat and MySQL.

Re:Startups Cooperative: Workable or Pie in the Sky Fantasy? by alaskamiller on Tuesday October 09, 2007 @05:05PM (#65475)
Who actually uses FogBugz? All his blog marketing does is make you think people use it but here in Silicon Valley I've rarely heard anyone use it.
Re:Startups Cooperative: Workable or Pie in the Sky Fantasy? by Andys on Friday October 12, 2007 @05:17AM (#66769)
I did a stint at a company who had bought it, and no one was using it. All the developers expressed disgust at its user-interface, and management didn't care what they used so they ended up writing their own.