Re:How Lavabit Melted Down
by smsm42 on Wednesday October 09, 2013 @01:40PM
(#6522645)
>>> That is like saying that GMail is protecting the privacy of your headers, because GMail uses SSL.
It does. Unlike Lavabit, though, there is ample reason to assume they invalidate this protection by granting governmental adversaries access to the information stored on their servers - the thing that Lavabit refused to do, at least on mass scale.
>>> since all the cryptographic operations were performed on the server.
I don't see what precludes you from sending emails already encrypted. Security has layers. You are not limited to using just one.
>>> leaves the server unable to fulfill demands for plaintexts.
You forgot to read the part of my answer where I use the word "envelope".
>>> Really, you think I am not using email anymore if I am running my own personal mail server?
It is irrelevant what you personally are doing - it is relevant what Lavabit was trying to do. They were trying to provide certain service - for people that - like, I assume, most of Guardian journalists - are not technically advanced enough to run a secure mail server on their personal computer and set up everything else in a way that allows it to accept email from the internet. This proved impossible, thus Lavabit is not with us anymore. That was my whole point.
>>> Ladar could have sold smartcards instead of selling cryptography as a service.
He could also have sold hotdogs and Carribean timeshares, how that's related to the topic? He was trying to create a secure email as a service - for those that can not create the same by themselves, which in 99.999% of the population of email users. Not provide solution for completely different problem such as key exchange and creating VPNs and other stuff.
It does. Unlike Lavabit, though, there is ample reason to assume they invalidate this protection by granting governmental adversaries access to the information stored on their servers - the thing that Lavabit refused to do, at least on mass scale.
>>> since all the cryptographic operations were performed on the server.
I don't see what precludes you from sending emails already encrypted. Security has layers. You are not limited to using just one.
>>> leaves the server unable to fulfill demands for plaintexts.
You forgot to read the part of my answer where I use the word "envelope".
>>> Really, you think I am not using email anymore if I am running my own personal mail server?
It is irrelevant what you personally are doing - it is relevant what Lavabit was trying to do. They were trying to provide certain service - for people that - like, I assume, most of Guardian journalists - are not technically advanced enough to run a secure mail server on their personal computer and set up everything else in a way that allows it to accept email from the internet. This proved impossible, thus Lavabit is not with us anymore. That was my whole point.
>>> Ladar could have sold smartcards instead of selling cryptography as a service.
He could also have sold hotdogs and Carribean timeshares, how that's related to the topic? He was trying to create a secure email as a service - for those that can not create the same by themselves, which in 99.999% of the population of email users. Not provide solution for completely different problem such as key exchange and creating VPNs and other stuff.