Re:Bring Back the Lash: Why flogging is more humane than pri...
by lake99 on Wednesday October 09, 2013 @01:09PM
(#6522462)
I see your point. Though I've not made up my mind about corporal punishment (as a step forward), I am concerned that whip-happy policemen might abuse it just the way they abuse tasers now.
In other words, our current system uses prison as a means of punishment and vengeance. I'm not saying that's a good thing; I'm just saying that corporal punishment has a very low bar to clear before we can say it's more humane than the awful status quo. (Yes, rape-free prisons would also be an improvement, and probably a more realistically achievable improvement, though I disagree with the methods you suggest.)