Re:Bring Back the Lash: Why flogging is more humane than pri...
by enoch_r on Wednesday October 09, 2013 @12:13PM
(#6522152)
Many gangs are the black-market equivalent of corporations. They are economic and social entities that have evolved to profit in illegal markets. Unlike ordinary corporations, they cannot resolve disputes with courts--so they use violence. Unlike ordinary corporations, they cannot prevent theft by calling the cops--so they use violence. And, of course, because they're already facing very high prison sentences if caught, the marginal cost of committing additional crimes is lowered.
Removing a giant market for gangs wouldn't just send gangs to work in other markets. Many of them would go out of business. This is precisely what we saw during the time of Prohibition--entrepreneurial gangs took advantage of their new market opportunity when alcohol was made illegal. They went out of business, or their power was greatly reduced, when Prohibition ended.
Re:Bring Back the Lash: Why flogging is more humane than pri...
by rayiner on Wednesday October 09, 2013 @12:32PM
(#6522259)
I appreciate that point, but that's not really the nature of the gangs you see these days in Chicago, LA, etc. Aggressive RICO prosecution over the last few decades have already weeded out many of the "professional" gangs. What's left are a lot of gangs with amorphous leadership and quite young memberships, arising from conditions in segregated inner cities.
While I agree that the Drug War should be ended, I think people overstate how much of an impact that would have on our prison population. There are a lot of people in prison on drug charges because drug distribution is a core business of America's gangs. The drug war is at least in part a proxy war on gangs. Legalization would hurt the gangs, but it's not as if all those people would suddenly go straight. There's 1.4 million gang members in the U.S. The gangs would continue to operate, and if drugs were off the table, the gangs would go into some other business and end up in prison for some other reason.