News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Bring Back the Lash: Why flogging is more humane than pri... by peterwwillis on Wednesday October 09, 2013 @10:03AM (#6521256)
I propose that each six months of incarceration be exchanged for one lash.

Say what you will for the idea that corporal punishment might be effective in reducing crime. One lash for six months? Hell, anyone can take one lash. Some people would gladly commit crimes for this benign sentence.

On the other hand, kids who grow up in a community where going to prison is normal (like the East Baltimore one of the author) are perfectly fine with going to jail. They even expect it. So committing crimes that brings you somewhere you were going to end up anyway, isn't such a big deal.

Actually changing the culture of a place would have a bigger effect on reducing crime than how we punish people for having committed it. The latter really depends on the former.

(Aside: i'm a much bigger fan of self-flagellation for punishment than having someone else do it, as you get the mental terror of having to hurt yourself along with the pain. You can only blame yourself for how you feel vs blaming some masked bogeyman)

There are no comments on this comment yet.