News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Nest introduces their Smoke Detector by DanBC on Tuesday October 08, 2013 @06:25PM (#6518253)
> The issue I believe is that enough of us in our home have experienced enough false alarms that basically give us a 'boy who cried wolf' mentality when it comes down to it.

I'm a bit confused.

What the hell kind of shoddy product are you people buying that triggers on something that isn't smoke? Or are people talking about situations where there is smoke, from something burning, but that burn is small and contained and safe?

EG Burning the toast - you don't need an alarm because you know it's the toast. Except it's possible for toasters to stick and for the bread to catch fire and for that to spread to the kitchen cupboard which is over the toaster, and etc. Some people don't stay in the room when the toast is cooking.

Better placement of the alarms - not in bathrooms or just outside bathroom doors, and not in kitchens or just outside kitchen doors - helps.

> a mine detector would give off a false alarm every time it came across a stick, people would fail to heed its warning in a real situation. They in effect would learn to ignore it and then that one time they did go in a minefield they'd be blown to bits.

Smoke detectors are detecting smoke. They're not detecting cups of coffee or Bic biros or other unrelated things.

Re:Nest introduces their Smoke Detector by joyeuse6701 on Tuesday October 08, 2013 @07:52PM (#6518645)
You're right, a smoke detector is detecting smoke... but some smoke is expected (like cooking) and some smoke isn't. The product addresses the problem of context. When we expect the smoke, it is a false positive, when we don't...it's positive. Many of us have made the mistake of ripping out the battery in frustration and leaving the smoke detector disabled despite the risk of living without a smoke detector.

As for your proposed solution. Drilling holes in the walls and ceilings, re-patching the the old installation point and doing this over and over to try and find a balance point of safe and convenient seems to fail the cost-benefit analysis compared to this product for me. I'd much rather buy the damn thing, leave it installed where it is as opposed to shifting it around.

My analogy of the mine detector was more about false positives in general usage, I guess if I were to correct it further, it would be a mine detector that couldn't detect an inactive/benign mine vs a malicious one.

Re:Nest introduces their Smoke Detector by DanBC on Tuesday October 08, 2013 @07:58PM (#6518669)
So, people put smoke detectors in bad places. Why do they do this? The boxes in the UK clearly tell you where to put them.

Other people move into that property, and remove the batteries. Leaving the cover open? Leaving a flashing LED? Leaving a "no battery chirp"?

> Drilling holes in the walls and ceilings, re-patching the the old installation point and doing this over and over to try and find a balance point of safe and convenient

Measure twice, cut once and all that. :-p

I realise that I made many posts about this, but I do agree with you. Many people do it, and it is a problem, and it's good that companies are thinking about getting working detectors into homes, and I look forward to hearing about Nest saving lives because people have working detectors and not detectors without batteries or somesuch.

Re:Nest introduces their Smoke Detector by mirsadm on Tuesday October 08, 2013 @07:04PM (#6518439)
What exactly are you confused about? Scenario A 1) Toast burns, no fire but lots of smoke 2) Alarm goes off, it's annoying so you wave your hand and turn it off. Problem solved.

Scenario B 1) Toast burns, catches fire and your whole kitchen is burning down. 2) You run like hell

Why would being able to disable a false alarm easier make it any less safer?

Edit: I'll also point out that EVERY single time we cook a steak in a cast iron pan in our apartment the smoke alarm will go off. It's really annoying I have to be the one trying to figure out how to silence the damn thing.

Re:Nest introduces their Smoke Detector by DanBC on Wednesday October 09, 2013 @06:41AM (#6520433)
But it's not a false alarm. Smoke detectors detect smoke; toast burns; smoke detector triggers. That's a real alarm.

There are two solutions: 1) make it easier to temporarily dismiss the alarm. 2) read the instructions and place the device properly