Re:One Hour Hire - Hacking Engineer Interviews
by elbear on Tuesday October 08, 2013 @06:04PM
(#6518121)
Maybe it works for them, but I don't find any motivation to work on test project that exist only for their own sake. I mean, if the test project is actually a part of the real project that I would be working, then that's okay. But to build something with made up requirements puts me off.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:One Hour Hire - Hacking Engineer Interviews
by shiftb on Tuesday October 08, 2013 @06:07PM
(#6518148)
The challenges are all real projects that we've already built (and thus have a baseline for).
We don't agree with brainteaser interviews. Having someone build a made up project would be just as bad as a brainteaser. We wouldn't do that to a candidate.
Re:One Hour Hire - Hacking Engineer Interviews
by patmcc on Tuesday October 08, 2013 @06:10PM
(#6518163)
So you believe in 8 hours * 99 applications (792 hours total - 4 months of work) of wasted time (not even your time) per hire?
Re:One Hour Hire - Hacking Engineer Interviews
by shiftb on Tuesday October 08, 2013 @06:27PM
(#6518262)
It is a lot less time than you calculated. We stop the process any time they don't pass and give them specific feedback on why. Usually, this is during the initial phone call/basic test. Most candidates do 30 minutes at most, which seems very reasonable when applying for a position.
Re:One Hour Hire - Hacking Engineer Interviews
by rhizome on Tuesday October 08, 2013 @07:38PM
(#6518582)
What's the difference between a brainteaser and a problem you've already solved?
Re:One Hour Hire - Hacking Engineer Interviews
by shiftb on Tuesday October 08, 2013 @09:23PM
(#6518940)
That's a good question. I hope this example gives some clarity to what I meant:
* Worthless Brainteaser: How many golfballs will fit in this Ford?
* Real-world Problem: Let's do cohort analysis on our users and see how our business is doing.
Part of the goal is also a consistent rubric for evaluating candidates.
In the past, we've tried giving every candidate a new problem to solve. It's not fair to them. When each problem is a brand new project it's difficult to evaluate a candidate objectively and consistently.
Re:One Hour Hire - Hacking Engineer Interviews
by Iftheshoefits on Tuesday October 08, 2013 @07:55PM
(#6518657)
Their problems are special and important.