The e-mail again confirmed that Lavabit is capable of providing the means for the FBI to
install the pen-trap device and obtain the requested information in an unencrypted form.
AUSA[censored] replied to Mr. Levison's e-mail that same day, explaining that the
proposal was inadequate because, among other things, it did not provide for real-time
transmission of results...
---Then, "The prosecutors informed Mr. Levison that the pen register is a devise used to monitor ongoing email traffic on a realtime basis and providing the FBI with data after 60 days was not sufficient."
So, I am not sure what to think. After some research I couldn't tell whether "pen register" data is required to be real-time. The original order on page 7 doesn't seem to say "real time", but there could be some legalese or other laws that imply it.
Levison was clearly dragging his feet, but it seems sort of bizarre that they escalated their demands in response. Why not just get him charged with contempt and move from there? Since they played the "we can't trust him since he's been uncooperative" card, does this mean they would have trusted him if he complied immediately? What if he immediately turned over info and it didn't help their investigation or went counter to their preconceived notions -- would they have accused him of withholding some and demanded his private keys anyway?
There's weird things on both sides here. It sounds like Levison's actions on the whole are not very defensible though. :/
Search for "$" on this page: http://paranoia.dubfire.net/2009/12/8-million-reasons-for-re... It is very common for third party service providers to search records themselves on behalf of law enforcement, and law enforcement has historically trusted that and even compensated them.
It's the only way that really makes sense IMO. Can the FBI really bust down, say, Verizon's doors, seize all their hard drives, and correctly generate evidence based on systems that aren't theirs, and may in fact be unique among the phone systems of the entire world? Maybe an email system is simpler, but still.
Also, I think it's inappropriate to seize 400,000 users' data just to (ostensibly) get to one person. But I'm not a lawyer, maybe it is arguably legal.
P.S. Also see https://www.eff.org/files/filenode/social_network/Yahoo_SN_L... for all the things Yahoo does on behalf of LE.