News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Nest introduces their Smoke Detector by eli on Tuesday October 08, 2013 @11:51AM (#6515776)
Have you tried pushing the "test" button while it's going off? On mine it's "test/silence" and works exactly as you describe. This is a very common feature and in some places is actually required by building code.

It's unsafe to encourage people to pull the battery during a false alarm.

Re:Nest introduces their Smoke Detector by umsm on Tuesday October 08, 2013 @01:41PM (#6516497)
The beauty of the nest device is that it doesn't need a button. All you need to do is wave.

A button requires you grab a chair or broom to activate... and that can be dangerous. Additionally, those test buttons work for 2 mins before it starts sounding again.

Re:Nest introduces their Smoke Detector by giardini on Wednesday October 09, 2013 @02:22AM (#6519704)
You can buy a smoke alarm with a "Hush" button separate from the test button. Press the hush button and the alarm won't go off for the next 15 minutes. Easy & cheap. Since alarms are usually mounted near the ceiling, it helps to be tall.

Some smoke alarms have the battery holder in the front - pressing a button opens the battery holder and turns off alarm power. This is a de facto hush feature, albeit less safe than a hush button (because people will often forget to close the battery holder, leaving the alarm disabled).

I do not understand why people buy the cheapest possible smoke alarms for $8 rather than spend $13 to buy one with a hush button or $20 to buy one with hush + lithium battery (~10 year) built-in, e.g.,

http://www.homedepot.com/p/Kidde-10-Year-Lithium-Battery-Ope...

In a very small condo I have two smoke alarms upstairs, two downstairs and an extra one that I just put here and there for fun (for instance, in it's current location it tells me when my neighbor is smoking outside his back door adjacent to my unit). I also have a CO alarm that _never_ goes off unless I'm testing it.

When I was a condominium association president I first offered free smoke alarm batteries. I soon realized that some would not ask for batteries and others would remove them from units. So instead I offered them an upgrade: new smoke alarms with hush + lifetime lithium battery which they could not disable without destroying. Problem almost solved: when in a unit I would sometimes find the new smoke alarm lying on a counter, uninstalled. I then offered to install alarms.

I was, of course, not surprised to read today's drudgereport headline: "FEDERAL GOVERNMENT: American adults dumber than average human". We now seem to live in an idiocracy:

http://www.imdb.com/find?q=idiocracy&s=all

Re:Nest introduces their Smoke Detector by kvnwng on Wednesday October 09, 2013 @11:27AM (#6521811)
I don't think a $100 premium is worth that especially considering placement can solve many of those issues. What WOULD be worth the $100 premium is if the sensors combined with the Nest thermostat could give me a better picture of my environmental health settings in the household or workplace. However, I don't think Fadell & co are prepared to launch something like that yet. I'll pass on the Protect and wait for something else.

The nest thermostat on the other hand is one the top of my list if/when I get my own long-term home.

Re:Nest introduces their Smoke Detector by beambot on Tuesday October 08, 2013 @01:56PM (#6516619)
What if I start running around waving... because there's a bloody fire!? (That's a really bad false positive!)
Re:Nest introduces their Smoke Detector by ajanuary on Tuesday October 08, 2013 @02:14PM (#6516755)
If there's a fire to the extent you're continually waving within 8 feet of the sensor then chances are it's one of the alarm types you can't silence [1]

[1] http://support.nest.com/article/What-types-of-alarms-can-I-s...

Re:Nest introduces their Smoke Detector by beambot on Tuesday October 08, 2013 @03:43PM (#6517341)
I'd rather not take that "chance."
Re:Nest introduces their Smoke Detector by PCheese on Wednesday October 09, 2013 @01:31AM (#6519584)
Then you would just disable the "wave" function in the software, requiring a button press to hush the alarm.
Re:Nest introduces their Smoke Detector by jcater on Tuesday October 08, 2013 @02:22PM (#6516812)
Then you probably already know your house is on fire?
Re:Nest introduces their Smoke Detector by xenophanes on Tuesday October 08, 2013 @03:40PM (#6517320)
But someone else might not know and need the alarm to keep going off.
Re:Nest introduces their Smoke Detector by darkarmani on Tuesday October 08, 2013 @05:09PM (#6517876)
Luckily you can't silence alarms only warnings.
Re:Nest introduces their Smoke Detector by dekz on Tuesday October 08, 2013 @07:53PM (#6518648)
Re:Nest introduces their Smoke Detector by adriancooney on Tuesday October 08, 2013 @03:53PM (#6517398)
Isn't it supposed to alert you that there's a fire? If your waving your arms around due to a fire, I think it's job is done.
Re:Nest introduces their Smoke Detector by JeffL on Tuesday October 08, 2013 @01:04PM (#6516246)
The ones I've had, even when you hit the "hush" button, it still makes a loud chirp every 60 seconds to let you know that it's hushed, but still detects smoke. This chirp scares the crap out of my dog.
Re:Nest introduces their Smoke Detector by eli on Tuesday October 08, 2013 @01:10PM (#6516303)
Fair enough.

Offtopic, but I used to rent a room in a huge old row house here in DC with a fancy "networked" fire alarm system. When one goes off, they all go off. You could turn it off by holding a button on the alarm... but it had to be the alarm that went off first. Makes sense from a design standpoint, but as far as I know there was no immediate way to determine which alarm that was, so there was a lot of running around with a broomstick (tall ceilings) pushing buttons.

Re:Nest introduces their Smoke Detector by ilyanep on Tuesday October 08, 2013 @03:34PM (#6517275)
In the college dorm I lived in, there was one networked system for the entire building (which was four ~80-bed dorms). It was so ridiculous that most people just stopped leaving when a fire alarm went off (the buildings are made of concrete and other not really flammable materials because it's Southern California) but the administration claimed they couldn't turn down the sensitivity.
Re:Nest introduces their Smoke Detector by giardini on Wednesday October 09, 2013 @02:48AM (#6519767)
Most of these also have dual battery/120v power. So there are usually 3 wires coming into the alarm: two (black + white) for 120v power and the third (red) for 9v signal. The usual way around this feature/problem is to disable (disconnect) the signal line at each alarm.
Re:Nest introduces their Smoke Detector by ctdonath on Tuesday October 08, 2013 @11:08PM (#6519202)
More than once my dog has tried crawling thru the bathroom wall to escape the noise. False alarms got bad enough when I was learning to cook a steak right that just the sight of the cast-iron frying pan would send him into hiding.

Yes, majority of fire deaths involve a non-working detector. Considering how severely & irrationally people react to false positives, anything that calms people into not permanently disabling the device is good.