News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Meet the Nest Protect smoke and CO alarm by raldi on Tuesday October 08, 2013 @09:36AM (#6514730)
If you have any doubt that is a desperately-needed product right now, go read the Amazon reviews for literally any other smoke detector on the market.

Frustratingly, this news arrives just weeks too late for us.

Re:Meet the Nest Protect smoke and CO alarm by jeanjq on Tuesday October 08, 2013 @09:43AM (#6514777)
What is wrong with the $7.50 Kidde?

http://www.amazon.com/Kidde-Sentry-Battery-Operated-Ionizati...

Reviews seem good.

Re:Meet the Nest Protect smoke and CO alarm by raldi on Tuesday October 08, 2013 @09:58AM (#6514917)
We have this exact brand in our apartment. They (like almost all ionization-based smoke detectors) go off at the drop of a hat. And they're ear-splittingly loud. The kill switch is hard to press, and needs to be pressed every few minutes if you're, say, burning incense. And one day, when the battery gets low, they'll start chirping in the middle of the night, leading to a game of "Which one is it?!" as they somehow manage to make noise frequently enough to prevent sleep but infrequently enough to thwart identification of the dying one.

(Smoke detectors' low battery alerts always go off at night because battery output sags when the temperature goes down.)

Re:Meet the Nest Protect smoke and CO alarm by danparsonson on Tuesday October 08, 2013 @10:15AM (#6515061)
A smoke alarm being very loud and very sensitive is a feature to me, not a bug - I'd rather be annoyed from time to time than die of smoke inhalation in my sleep. As for 'hunt the low battery' - how many smoke alarms do you need in one area?
Re:Meet the Nest Protect smoke and CO alarm by raldi on Tuesday October 08, 2013 @10:24AM (#6515138)
False dichotomy. With an extra ten cents' worth of technology, the smoke detector could do its initial chirping quietly and during daylight hours. If you ignore them, then later it can escalate to around-the-clock 85-decibel alerts.

Ditto sensitivity. At the first wisps of a problem, give a gentle sound. If it gets worse, or 60 seconds pass, then get shrill.

Re: "how many do you need in one area?" the last three words do not apply. The low-battery chirp is loud enough that a dying battery anywhere in the house can wake you up. For the record, though, we were required to put one in every bedroom and two in our small hallway -- and that's just on our upper level.

Re:Meet the Nest Protect smoke and CO alarm by danparsonson on Tuesday October 08, 2013 @11:34AM (#6515649)
Have you seen how quickly an actual house fire takes hold? There are videos of fire department demonstrations on YouTube (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rUh4rCjuYDA for example). In sixty (or even ten) seconds of gentle sounds, you'd probably be dead. Not to mention that smoke can take time to rise up to smoke detector level - crucial seconds that you could be using to escape rather than comfortably waking up.

As for the low battery chirp, it should be annoying - that way you attend to it rather than leaving it until later. And chirping only during the daylight hours - how is that helpful if you're out at work? The battery will be dead before you even know about it.

Smoke alarms should be intrusive when they need your attention. That's how they save lives.

P.S. as for the last point - I was actually referring to how difficult it is to work out which smoke detector is chirping. Thus my question - I can't see how it's difficult unless you have lots of smoke alarms. Badly explained on my part, sorry.

Re:Meet the Nest Protect smoke and CO alarm by raldi on Tuesday October 08, 2013 @11:39AM (#6515699)
> In sixty (or even ten) seconds of gentle sounds, you'd probably be dead.

Which is why I also said that, if the problem gets worse that just a few wisps, the detector should immediately escalate to full alarm.

> And chirping only during the daylight hours - how is that helpful if you're out at work? The battery will be dead before you even know about it.

Again, it can start quiet and polite, and then escalate to more aggressive notifications if you ignore it.

Re:Meet the Nest Protect smoke and CO alarm by danparsonson on Tuesday October 08, 2013 @12:48PM (#6516148)
> Which is why I also said that, if the problem gets worse that just a few wisps, the detector should immediately escalate to full alarm.

Indeed, but personally I don't want a dumb electronic device to make that judgement for me - I'd like to do it myself. I'll know instantly whether or not the house is on fire and I'd like to know instantly whether or not it seems like it might be. False positives are, as I said earlier, infinitely preferable to "he'd have made it out if he'd heard the alarm earlier". Besides, how do you decide what's "house fire smoke" vs "burnt toast smoke"? if the fire isn't adjacent to the detector then smoke may only reach the detector slowly.

I get the drive to make devices more intelligent and thus more convenient but I strongly disagree that this philosophy should apply in all cases. Sometimes 'basic' really is better. Not to mention that there's less to go wrong.

Re:Meet the Nest Protect smoke and CO alarm by raldi on Tuesday October 08, 2013 @02:01PM (#6516651)
> Indeed, but personally I don't want a dumb electronic device to make that judgement for me

But ultimately, you have no choice. Even the ideal smoke detector that you have in mind is going to be a dumb electronic device that has to make a judgement for you.

It'll have some sort of threshold before the loud alarm goes off. I'm not suggesting that be changed.

What I'm suggesting is that, in addition to that, at an even more sensitive threshold, there be a quieter alarm, too.

Re:Meet the Nest Protect smoke and CO alarm by FireBringer on Tuesday October 08, 2013 @11:48AM (#6515750)
Usually smoke detectors are a 1 in each room (and 1 in the main hallway) thing nowadays.

And as for the hunt for the low battery it is a problem (though usually only one week a year if you install the same smoke detector in all rooms at the same time. And it is hard to find because it emits a high chirp every 30-60 seconds but that chirp echoes throughout the house and is hard to pinpoint (especially if you do have 1 in each room).

But I agree loud and sensitive better than the alternative and you can avoid accidental set offs by not having one located near the kitchen stove, though most of the time bad smoke detector locations are in apartments where you wouldn't have a choice to move them anyway.

Re:Meet the Nest Protect smoke and CO alarm by raldi on Tuesday October 08, 2013 @11:58AM (#6515822)
> But I agree loud and sensitive better than the alternative

You don't have to choose! If you want the loud alarm to go off when it detects X PPM, have a gentle alert go off when it detects (0.9 * X) PPM.

Re:Meet the Nest Protect smoke and CO alarm by uptown on Tuesday October 08, 2013 @09:58AM (#6514909)
The Nest is a photoelectric smoke sensor. The Kidde is an ionization sensor.

"Kidde strongly recommends that both ionization and photoelectric smoke alarms be installed to help insure maximum detection of the various types of fires that can occur within the home."

More info: http://consumerist.com/2010/08/25/fire-chief-most-smoke-alar...

Re:Meet the Nest Protect smoke and CO alarm by jeanjq on Tuesday October 08, 2013 @10:03AM (#6514963)
Interesting. It's sad, then, that Nest does not emphasise that fact.
Re:Meet the Nest Protect smoke and CO alarm by berberous on Tuesday October 08, 2013 @09:59AM (#6514927)
From a safety only perspective:

1) This doesn't detect carbon monoxide 2) One of the 1-star reviews states that Ionization alarms are old technology and unsafe compared to newer piezoelectric alarms.

Re:Meet the Nest Protect smoke and CO alarm by raldi on Tuesday October 08, 2013 @10:00AM (#6514941)
Photoelectric.
Re:Meet the Nest Protect smoke and CO alarm by kayoone on Tuesday October 08, 2013 @10:30AM (#6515187)
The Nest Thermostat isnt flawless either so i doubt the first version of this will be: http://www.amazon.com/Nest-Learning-Thermostat-Generation-T2...
Re:Meet the Nest Protect smoke and CO alarm by Udo on Tuesday October 08, 2013 @09:55AM (#6514890)
> Sadly, this news arrives just weeks too late for us.

What happened?

Re:Meet the Nest Protect smoke and CO alarm by raldi on Tuesday October 08, 2013 @10:00AM (#6514933)
I just bought ten ordinary smoke alarms.
Re:Meet the Nest Protect smoke and CO alarm by supercoder on Tuesday October 08, 2013 @10:01AM (#6514951)
My thoughts are with you and your family.
Re:Meet the Nest Protect smoke and CO alarm by raldi on Tuesday October 08, 2013 @10:04AM (#6514976)
:)

"Thoughts and prayers" would have been even more biting.

Re:Meet the Nest Protect smoke and CO alarm by corresation on Tuesday October 08, 2013 @10:05AM (#6514987)
So instead you would buy ten Nest alarms for $130 each?
Re:Meet the Nest Protect smoke and CO alarm by Udo on Tuesday October 08, 2013 @10:09AM (#6515009)
It's steep but then again, just the option of being notified about a fire when you're not at home makes me consider doing just that. When I'm away, I sometimes get a bad feeling and I check the surveillance cams remotely, but that's neither practical nor helpful. On the other hand, I probably wouldn't be so paranoid if there had never been a fire.
Re:Meet the Nest Protect smoke and CO alarm by raldi on Tuesday October 08, 2013 @10:30AM (#6515180)
It's a drop in the bucket compared to the enormously expensive fire sprinkler system we were forced to install by 2010 national building code.
Re:Meet the Nest Protect smoke and CO alarm by corresation on Tuesday October 08, 2013 @10:39AM (#6515249)
Okay if on the other end of the spectrum why wouldn't you have gone with a security/automation integrated system? As others have mentioned, Nest is clearly moving towards the home security space, where there are already many, many options for whole-home intelligence products that tell you remotely exactly what is going on, which fire alarm went off, allows you to control them from a touch panel (or a PC, smart phone or tablet), etc.

Ultimately that is what surprises me about Nest the most -- their products aren't doing anything new, but people who only ever made themselves aware of the ultra-low end compare Nest to a $9 smoke alarm and laud Nest for raising the bar...but the bar was raised years ago for those who are in that market.

Re:Meet the Nest Protect smoke and CO alarm by raldi on Tuesday October 08, 2013 @10:43AM (#6515287)
Nest makes it user-friendly.
Re:Meet the Nest Protect smoke and CO alarm by corresation on Tuesday October 08, 2013 @10:53AM (#6515343)
So you have trialed, for instance, the Honeywell Tuxedo Touch system? http://homesecurity.honeywell.com/tuxedo_touch.html

Nest is doing piecemeal what others do holistically (again, though, obviously because they want to do the whole thing one module at a time). I don't want a bunch of islands of home intelligence, but would rather have one home automation system. Which is why I made the point about cost -- it's one thing if your price range is $8 smoke alarms, but if you could seriously contemplate 10 Nest devices, you're a candidate for a real system.