Re:Scala: sharp and gets things cut
by pron on Monday October 07, 2013 @03:03PM
(#6510425)
I don't value purity; I value coherence, and a good sense of direction. I would take JVM interoperability over purity any day, because the value of whatever compromise this entails far exceeds its cost.
In fact, I don't even consider it a compromise because for all their strengths, neither Haskell nor Erlang solve all problems. In that respect Scala is right. Scala is wrong, however, to think that each concept's deficiencies need to be addressed in the same language. It could have worked in theory, maybe, but the result in practice turned out an ugly mess.
I believe in combining forces through a few languages that interoperable over one platform, and the JVM achieves this quite well.
> And even when they maybe do (e.g., Erjang exists) they don't provide easy access to the ecosystem.
Sure they do. Erjang (and Frege, for that matter) support straightforward integration with Java.
In fact, I don't even consider it a compromise because for all their strengths, neither Haskell nor Erlang solve all problems. In that respect Scala is right. Scala is wrong, however, to think that each concept's deficiencies need to be addressed in the same language. It could have worked in theory, maybe, but the result in practice turned out an ugly mess.
I believe in combining forces through a few languages that interoperable over one platform, and the JVM achieves this quite well.
> And even when they maybe do (e.g., Erjang exists) they don't provide easy access to the ecosystem.
Sure they do. Erjang (and Frege, for that matter) support straightforward integration with Java.