News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:In Defense of Selling Out by jerf on Monday October 07, 2013 @01:24PM (#6509729)
While your distinction is a useful one, I think it's not a common one. Just as there seems to be some sort of cultural rush to be the first to declare something has jumped the shark, there's a very strong presumption that selling simply is selling out, a conclusion that can be leaped to without anything so tedious as examining the facts, and some sort of rush to be the first and loudest to so declare.
Re:In Defense of Selling Out by mjn on Monday October 07, 2013 @01:47PM (#6509900)
It could be that I discuss in odd circles, but the distinction between the two seems pretty commonly raised in my experience. Common to the extent that arguing over which side of the dividing line a particular sale falls is the key question often debated. The "con" side will argue that a given sale is not only a sale in the literal sense, but selling out in the more ethical sense of failing to do right by one's fans/customers/whatever, letting the cash being dangled lure you into doing something you wouldn't normally do. For example, when CDDB "sold out" to Gracenote, which took it proprietary, the problem wasn't just that CDDB sold at all, but that the trustees of a community project sold out their community's trust for a cash payment.

The "pro" side will typically argue that a given sale is just changing ownership structure but not fundamentally auctioning off their values/trust/etc.